The New York Times
May 18, 2005
Failing the Sniff Test: The Nose, Ruined
By Paul Lukas
ROBERT WEINSTOCK doesn’t remember the accident.
“It was Oct. 7, 2003, and I was going to get a prescription from my doctor,” he recalled recently. “It was just two blocks away, but I was running late, so I took my bicycle. I’d only been biking for about five seconds when I turned a corner. The next thing I remember is waking up in the hospital.”
Mr. Weinstock, a 37-year-old illustrator and children’s book author who lives in Greenwich Village, soon learned that he had been hit by a truck, resulting in a broken arm, hearing loss in one ear, spinal fluid leakage and a fractured skull. He spent two weeks in the hospital, where he underwent two spinal taps and skull surgery.
Given the gravity of his injuries, Mr. Weinstock didn’t worry too much about how his food was tasting. “My mother was bringing me soup from some fancy market,” he said, “and I realized at some point that it all tasted like chicken fat, schmaltz. I didn’t say anything, because I figured there was just something off with the food.”
But after he left the hospital, he realized the problem was wide-ranging.
“Coffee smelled a bit rank, anything with garlic tasted horrible – and I always loved garlic!” he said. “Then I had mint chocolate chip ice cream, one of my favorite foods, and it tasted really chemical-y.”
Mr. Weinstock was experiencing a loss of smell, or anosmia. Because smell and taste are so closely related, anosmia patients usually complain first about food that doesn’t taste right. They find themselves in a world where they can no longer take for granted that chocolate will taste like chocolate, longtime favorites are suddenly unpleasant, and the parameters of good and bad flavor, or ripe and spoiled, become a guessing game. A lifetime’s worth of learned assumptions and preferences are sent back to square one.
“The taste buds can only detect sweet, sour, salty and bitter – the full symphony of flavor comes from the nose,” said Dr. Charles P. Kimmelman, a Manhattan anosmia specialist. “But when your brain is hit really hard, it wiggles like Jell-O, and the little fibers going from the smell nerve endings up to the brain are stretched taut. Some of them get torn, injured or bruised.”
Can the damaged fibers regenerate? “To a certain extent,” Dr. Kimmelman said. “But not necessarily along the same pathways they had before. It’s like a crossed circuit. And there’s usually a phantom sensation, like when a person loses a foot but still feels like his toe is hurting. The brain is trying to make sense of what little information it has coming in.”
So some things may be perceived differently than they were before the injury, and others may not be perceived at all. Dr. Kimmelman said that most anosmia patients recover only 20 to 30 percent of their sensory function, and that there is little doctors can do about it.
Anosmia may be caused not only by head trauma but also by upper respiratory infection, nasal or sinus disease and exposure to toxins. Some people are born with the condition. People from all these camps usually find their way to a Yahoo anosmia message board (health.groups.yahoo.com/group/anosmia) that has emerged as a popular support group.
Many anosmic people say the biggest challenge is in the kitchen. “I wasn’t a great cook to begin with, but with anosmia you can’t tell when something’s burning,” said Lori Mesnik, a computer consultant from Edison, N.J., who suffered a head injury in December. “One time I steamed some broccoli, and it wasn’t until I cleaned up later that evening that I realized the water had boiled out and burned the Teflon from the inside of the pot.”
Another common complaint: dealing with the frequent perception that compared with other disabilities, anosmia is no big deal.
“Most people treat me like a circus oddity,” said Maria Topper, a school science coordinator from Oceanside, Calif., who became anosmic about two years ago, apparently because of allergies. “They do not realize how much of a life-changing experience it is to lose these senses.”
Mr. Weinstock initially played down his condition.
“At first my attitude was that I was grateful not to be a vegetable,” he said. “I thought, ‘If this is the worst I have to deal with, that’s fine.’ But it did take a lot of the joy out of eating. It was deflating to bite into something and have it taste bad.”Because eating is such a social activity, he sometimes felt left out at dinner gatherings. Restaurant outings became crapshoots at best, pointless extravagances at worst.”
But the problems of this condition go beyond culinary inconvenience. Anosmic patients may not be able to smell a gas leak or a fire, and they can unwittingly eat spoiled food. Mr. Weinstock once handed a milk carton to his girlfriend, Dana Stevens, who poured milk in her coffee and discovered it had turned sour. Mr. Weinstock, completely oblivious, had already finished his cereal.
Mr. Weinstock was eventually referred to Dr. Kimmelman, who gave him the University of Pennsylvania Smell Identification Test, considered the gold standard for assessing olfactory function (available from smelltest.com for $26.95; minimum order seven tests). Mr. Weinstock initially thought he’d done “fairly well” on the test but was disappointed to hear that his score placed him among the bottom 5 percent of the population. “That’s when it began seeming more real,” he said. “I realized this was going to be a problem.”
Undaunted, Mr. Weinstock slowly began orienting himself to his reconfigured palate. “Thai, Japanese and fruit were O.K., but almost anything else tasted off,” he said. “Anything with a sauce or a melding of flavors tasted muddy and schmaltzy. Processed foods like candy, soda and toothpaste were very chemical-y, almost astringent.”
Ms. Stevens, a freelance journalist who occasionally writes film reviews for The New York Times, helped out by setting up blind taste tests for Mr. Weinstock. She primarily used ice creams and sorbets, since they all had similar, neutral textures. Slowly but steadily, Mr. Weinstock showed progress: At first he couldn’t tell chocolate ice cream from vanilla, but later on he successfully distinguished between the relatively similar coffee and dulce de leche. Both he and Ms. Stevens remember that as a milestone.
“My theory was that immersion therapy would help – lots of stimulus, lots of flavors,” Ms. Stevens said. “Besides, the alternative seemed so grim. At one point I found this anosmia web site where people posted messages like, ‘There’s more to food than flavor – there’s still texture and color and temperature!’ And that just seemed depressing, like, ‘Ah, here’s a red cube, and it’s tepid, oh boy!’ The taste tests made me feel like we were working on something, making progress.”
Whatever the impetus, Mr. Weinstock’s taste sense appears to have improved.“I’ve definitely gotten better at eating things with garlic, especially cooked garlic,” he said. “In general, there are more things that taste good. And I’m better at understanding what tastes good and what doesn’t.”
At a Brooklyn cafe recently, he tucked into a lemon buttermilk souffle with obvious gusto.
Although he estimates that he’s recovered about 70 percent of his taste capacity, he concedes that this could simply be a matter of acclimating to his new sensory environs – after all, he initially thought he did well on the smell identification test, too. Taste, it turns out, is a difficult thing to pin down.
“It’s like asking a kid, ‘Do you feel taller today?’” he said. “Any changes have been happening so gradually that it’s hard to tell. I’ve had more than a year to forget what it was that I lost.”
One thing he hasn’t forgotten: his old favorite, mint chocolate chip ice cream – or “mint chocolate R.I.P.,” as he now calls it. “I kept trying it, but eventually I gave up, because it became too dispiriting,” he said. His new favorite foods are blood orange juice and salad.
“And as sad as it may sound, vanilla may now be my favorite ice cream. It tastes very vanilla-y.” He paused, and then added: “Or at least how I remember vanilla tasting.”
The Daily Telegraph
August 22, 2005
Scent is not to be sniffed at; We underestimate the importance of our sense of smell to our wellbeing – as Barbara Lantin discovered when she lost hers. That’s on top of all the other duties it discharges
It was when my children sniffed the fish meant for supper and reeled backwards, holding their noses and pretending to vomit, that I knew I had to do something about my missing sense of smell. Until then, I had considered its absence inconvenient and somewhat depressing – mainly because I could not taste anything properly. Suddenly, I realised it could seriously damage my health.
“Smell is the Cinderella sense,” says Dr Glenys Scadding, consultant allergist and rhinologist at the Royal National Throat, Nose and Ear Hospital in London. “One per cent of our DNA is devoted to it – a huge amount. Two to three per cent of the population have a reduced sense of smell and these people often get quite depressed, because it is as if all the colour is washed out of life. They are also in danger because they cannot detect fire, gas leaks or rotten food.”
According to Prof Tim Jacob, of the School of Biosciences at Cardiff University: “We certainly underestimate the importance of smell to our wellbeing. There are suggestions that it can influence mood, memory, emotions, mate choice, and the immune and endocrine systems. Every experience has a smell associated with it and people with anosmia – a reduced sense of smell – do not have access to that memory link.
“Anosmia can affect people socially, psychologically, and physiologically. It can lead to loss of libido – because a lot of human interaction is down to smell – and weight loss or gain, because people with no sense of taste either forget to eat or overcompensate by eating too much.”
The most common cause of smell loss is a nasal blockage, usually – as in my case – due to polyps. Damage to the olfactory nerves from a heavy cold, trauma or inhaling certain chemicals has the same effect. Some illnesses, including Parkinson’s and schizophrenia, impair the ability to smell, and loss of olfactory sensitivity can be an early indicator of Alzheimer’s.
Surgery used to be the only treatment for polyps, but doctors now carry out medical polypectomies using short-term oral and nasal steroids followed by mild steroid drops. This approach worked for me and though I’ll never make a wine taster or a parfumeur, I can now tell when the fish is off.
“We all have our own unique smell by which we can be recognised,” says Prof Jacob. “Children can distinguish between the smell of their siblings and other children of the same age. Babies recognise their own mother’s smell and mothers recognise their own baby’s.”
Research has shown that emotions, including fear, happiness and sexual arousal, can be communicated through smell. “Recent research has shown that women can discriminate between armpit swabs taken from people watching ‘happy’ and ‘sad’ films, though men were less good at this,” says Prof Jacob. Women have a more acute sense of smell, particularly during ovulation and pregnancy.
Scent and attraction
The role of smell in sexual attraction is more complex than perfume makers would have us believe. Pheromones, powerful chemicals emitted from the skin, are not smelled consciously, but are thought to be detected by the vomeronasal organ, a receptor in the nose.
“Smell is a very important component in partner choice,” says Prof Jacob, “because we are attracted to people with a dissimilar immune system to our own - so that our offspring have increased disease resistance – and your immune system determines your odour type.”
But male sweat is not an irresistible turn-on, he says.
“The male pheromone androstenol, the scent produced by fresh male sweat, is attractive to females,” says Kate Fox, author of the Social Issues Research Council’s Smell Report. “But androstenone, produced by male sweat after exposure to oxygen – in other words, when less fresh – is perceived as highly unpleasant.”
Different smells can produce various physiological effects, but it is not known exactly how. Studies show that aromatherapy treatments can reduce stress. Lavender has been shown to improve sleep and rosemary to act as a stimulant. When the air in a Moscow classroom was scented with peppermint, pupils performed better in some tests.
Some experts put these results down to conditioning, but Dr Judy Howie, an aromatherapist and scientist at Thames Valley University, believes that there is more to aromatherapy than mere suggestion.
“Certain components in aromatherapy oils interact with various biochemical receptors in the nervous system to help rebalance the body,” she says. “The combination of emotional and physiological effects occurring at the same time can be very powerful.”
Smell and memory
“Whole memories, complete with associated emotions, can be prompted by smell and this is entirely unconscious,” says Prof Jacob. This key to our sense of smell lies not in the nose but much farther up the nasal passage, in the olfactory epithelium, which contains olfactory receptor cells. These are directly connected to the limbic system, the most ancient and primitive part of the brain, thought to be the seat of emotion - which may explain why odours can trigger deep-seated feelings and memories. Although the sense of smell diminishes as we get older, odour memory remains when other recollections have faded.
September 24, 2005
The unbearable absence of smelling; Suddenly losing your sense of smell can remove all pleasure from food and drink. Doctors say it’s untreatable, but Mick O’Hare didn’t take no for an answer
One Friday in June 1998, I sat down with a curry for a self-indulgent night watching the soccer World Cup on TV. I had no idea how my next words would signal a momentous change in my life: “I can’t taste anything,” I told my wife.
She pointed out that I had a cold. True, I had struggled through the week with a dreadful sore throat, and by now the infection had spread to my nose and sinuses. But I knew immediately that my problem wasn’t simply the nasal congestion that everyone suffers now and then with a cold. It was a total absence of any sense of taste or smell.
I spent the next week sniffing everything from herb jars to dog muck: nothing. It was terrifying. As someone who loves food and drink, my life had been turned upside down in an instant. My wife and I were enthusiastic cooks – we even planned holidays based on local cuisines and took wine-tasting classes –and I was a member of CAMRA, the UK’s real ale club. It was all suddenly meaningless.
My general practitioner’s advice was less than encouraging. Like most GPs, she had no experience of my situation and could offer no helpful advice. Wait and see, was all she could say. So as many patients do, I hit the internet. I found the names of my afflictions: I had become ageusic, lacking a sense of taste, and anosmic, lacking a sense of smell.
I quickly realised that the anosmia troubled me more. Most of what we call taste is actually flavour produced by the smell of the food passing into our nasal cavities. True taste is only the bitter, sweet, salt, sour and “umami,” or savouriness, detected by the tongue’s taste buds. Bite into a strawberry and your tongue only tells you that it is sweet; it is the odours rising through your throat to your nose that tell you that particular sweetness is strawberry-flavoured.
I discovered the truth of this when, over the next couple of months, my sense of taste gradually returned. The bitterness of green peppers and the sweetness of chocolate began slowly to seep back. Yet agonisingly, smell and flavour remained entirely absent.
At my insistence, my GP referred me to a succession of ear, nose and throat (ENT) specialists. Their verdict was devastating: I had to live with it. My sense of smell – and with it, everything from the faint flavour of lettuce to the fierce assault of piri-piri chicken – had probably gone forever.
In desperation I continued my internet research. I discovered that while estimates vary, it is thought that anosmia affects about 0.66 per cent of the population in the US. Head injuries cause more than a third of cases, and cold and flu viruses account for about another third. Other causes include chronic sinus infections and nasal polyps.
I started to learn more about the sense I had taken for granted all my life. Our sense of smell, or olfaction, arises in a small patch of tissue high in the nasal cavity known as the olfactory epithelium . This contains about 50 million nerve cells, or neurons, that each bristle with minuscule hairs, or cilia, extending into the surface mucus. Airborne molecules that waft up the nostrils and dissolve in the mucus bind to receptor proteins on these cilia, triggering an electrical impulse in the neuron. The signal travels up to a kind of relay station called the olfactory bulb, just behind the olfactory epithelium. Further neurons, bundled together to form the olfactory nerve, pass these signals on to the brain.
Just how this system allows us to distinguish thousand of different smells was only discovered in the 1990s, in work that last year earned the US researchers, Richard Axel and Linda Buck, the Nobel prize for medicine. They discovered that each neuron in the olfactory epithelium makes just one type of about a thousand possible receptors. Each receptor is activated only by a specific odour molecule. Every odour produces its own characteristic pattern of firing neurons, which builds up the picture of the smell we experience, as if each odour has its own combinatorial bar code.
So what disrupts this system in anosmia? The standard medical opinion is that viral anosmia like mine, is a result of a cold or flu virus destroying olfactory epithelium neurons and damaging the cilia on any remaining ones. In rare cases the virus may also damage the olfactory nerve.
Alarmingly, a study by Thomas Hummell at the University of Dresden in Germany has shown that only a third of viral anosmics recover spontaneously. “If the damage is too great, the loss is permanent,” says Tim Jacob, an anosmia researcher at Cardiff University in the UK. “Currently, the standard belief is there is no effective medical treatment.”
As a future without flavour or smell beckoned, the sense of despair grew. I would wake at night consumed by the fear of never again tasting my mum’s Yorkshire puddings or my wife’s chocolate mousse. I began to dread eating. All I could experience was the colour and texture of the food while everyone else commented on the delicious flavours. And meals came round with agonising regularity, three times a day. They are unavoidable, because if you don’t join in, you die.
The thought of meeting friends in a social setting – which always, but always, involved a meal or a drink – meant I would find an excuse to decline invitations. But few people seemed to understand. Would you ask a deaf friend to a concert by the Royal Philharmonic Orchestra? And then, when you remember they can’t actually hear the soaring wonder of Beethoven’s ninth symphony, would you tell them they can at least watch the musicians pressing valves and waving bows? Nobody would be so insensitive. Yet that is how it is for an anosmic invited to dinner. “It sounds trivial and amusing, but it’s devastating,” one fellow sufferer told me soon after my condition arose. “Yet it’s the only disability where people laugh in your face when you tell them you have it.”
My options seemed to have run out. Then, about eight months later, I encountered Richard Firsten of Miami on an anosmia web forum. He had had symptoms identical to mine, yet he was now apparently recovering after treatment from Robert Henkin, a cognitive neurologist and director of the Washington DC Taste and Smell Clinic. Henkin has been studying taste and smell disorders since 1959, has published extensive research papers on taste and smell and founded the US National Institutes of Health’s first programme devoted to the evaluation of these senses.
My ENT doctors told me I’d be wasting time and money, but Richard’s testimony, coupled with what I learned of Henkin’s research, convinced me that Washington was my best hope. I headed there in May 1999, 11 months after the virus had struck.
Two days later, I had an entirely new perspective. Henkin was sceptical of the standard view that viral anosmia results from the virus killing olfactory epithelium cells. These normally regenerate constantly from a layer of stem cells that sits just above the olfactory epithelium. “The cells of the whole epithelium can be replaced via the stem cells within 30 days,” says Henkin. “So why doesn’t spontaneous recovery occur in all individuals?”
This paradox had caused Henkin to start looking for other explanations. “Something else was stopping olfaction being restored,” he says. He wondered if the virus’s lasting effect was not on the olfactory epithelium or nerve, but on something else. Henkin began to look at the structures that interacted with the epithelium, and this led him to the serous glands, which are located throughout the surface of the nasal mucosa.
These glands produce the nasal mucus that bathes the olfactory epithelium. This was already known to contain a number of substances such as enzymes and growth factors. Henkin began to speculate that the lasting damage done by the virus was actually to the serous glands, altering the composition of the mucus. Previous work by Henkin and others on cells grown in the lab had shown that the olfactory stem cells only grew and divided in the presence of nasal mucus, presumably because of the chemical growth factors it contained.
In the 1970s, Henkin started looking for these growth factors in nasal mucus. He concentrated on a small molecule called cyclic adenosine monophosphate (cAMP), which was known to act like a growth factor on nerve cells such as spinal cord neurons. Henkin measured levels of cAMP in the nasal mucus of viral anosmia patients. The results were intriguing. In patients with partial smell loss, or hyposmia, cAMP was lower than normal. In those with total loss, like me, it was lower still. The correlation was stark: the worse the smell loss, the lower the mucus cAMP (The FASEB Journal , vol 16, p A1153). Henkin concluded he had probably found the growth factor he was looking for. “Slowly, it clicked,” he says.
Henkin’s next task was to turn this finding into a treatment. He realised an existing medicine called theophylline might fit the bill. It had been used for decades to treat asthma because its main action is to open up the airways, but one of its other effects is to inhibit an enzyme called phosphodiesterase, which breaks down cAMP. So if someone’s serous glands were still producing a small amount of cAMP, theophylline treatment should help it hang around for longer, thus boosting levels of cAMP.
In 1977 Henkin began treating the first few anosmia patients with theophylline, selecting those who had failed to respond to any other form of treatment and who had low levels of cAMP. Within weeks many began to report improvements, to varying degrees. “If a patient naturally made little cAMP before their virus, it takes longer for theophylline to increase cAMP to the levels necessary to stimulate the stem cells,” says Henkin. In some theophylline had no effect, presumably because their serous glands no longer produced any cAMP.
Henkin continued to offer theophylline to the patients who came to his door, but he could not get funding to carry out a proper randomised controlled trial to compare theophylline with placebo. Drug firms were not interested in such a rare condition. “The companies do not feel that this old and common drug has much in it for them,” Henkin says.
Smelling the Coffee
By the time I turned up in 1999, although Henkin had published numerous papers on the possible mechanisms behind smell and taste disorders and how theophylline might increase cAMP levels, he had only published one small clinical trial of theophylline treatment. Out of four patients in the study, three had reported improvement. Henkin had, however, obtained objective confirmation of this result, because he had carried out brain scans using functional magnetic resonance imaging on the patients, before and after the treatment, and also on healthy volunteers. Beforehand, the patients showed much less activity than the controls in several areas of the brain that normally respond to smell. After treatment, the three who responded to theophylline showed increased activity in those brain areas, but the non-responder didn’t (Journal of Computer-Assisted Tomography , vol 22, p 760).
So should I go ahead with the treatment? Because I couldn’t spend the rest of my life anosmic and wondering “what if?”, there was simply no other option.
At first progress was slow. But within four months, hints of smell began to return. Early one morning as the coffee brewed at work, I recognised something that had been missing for more than a year. I could barely contain my emotion. By the time the week was out I had smelt perfume, tar setting on the London streets and herbs emanating from the local pizzeria – all muted, but present. It was another 18 months before I was back to normal, but once I knew I was on the road to recovery, my feeling of relief and my new-found appreciation of my returning sense was overwhelming.
But Henkin’s work has not become mainstream medical opinion. Bruce Jafek, professor of otolaryngology at the University of Colorado in Boulder, for example, agrees viral anosmia may well be caused by problems with regeneration of the olfactory epithelium, but says it is unclear whether this stems from changes in the mucus.
Theophylline is not approved for the treatment of anosmia, and in the absence of a placebo-controlled trial, it is unlikely to be widely accepted as such. And while it is generally considered a safe drug, it can cause side-effects similar to those of caffeine, such as agitation, headaches and gastrointestinal problems. At higher doses it can be positively dangerous, and can interact badly with other drugs such as the antibiotic ciprofloxacin.
“The use of theophylline is not proven,” says Jafek. “And the treatment has yet to be replicated by other researchers.” He acknowledges, however, that “theophylline has been used safely in asthma treatment for years, so is not, if administered correctly, hazardous”.
Henkin has still not gained funding for a trial, although he is preparing a paper reviewing 230 patients who have received theophylline at the clinic over the last 10 years. This will report that 70 per cent experienced significant improvement, which is certainly higher than the spontaneous recovery rate of 33 per cent seen in Hummell’s study. But then again, that figure may have been an underestimate, because people who suffer a temporary bout of anosmia are less likely to report it to their doctor. Only a formal trial would give us the true picture.
Henkin also reports that out of those who responded to theophylline, about a third have been able to stop treatment without regressing. Another third, however, found that their sense of smell diminished, although resumption of treatment restored it. The remaining third have not attempted to stop treatment.
I am in that last group. I know my recovery could have been a coincidence, but I am ecstatic that I can once again appreciate every smell, however nasty, and every meal, however ordinary. Of course, no two people are alike – we all have different ideas about what constitutes nectar from the gods – but here are some of mine: a pint of Black Sheep ale, my grandmother’s beef and potato pie, newly mown grass, a glass of Rioja, fish and chips from my home town of Cleckheaton, Serrano ham, freshly oiled cricket bats, roasted peppers, stilton cheese, my wife (these are in no particular order, you understand), my son... I could go on and on.
I Don’t Smell a Thing; When Your Nose Doesn’t Work Right, It’s Hard to
Tell Chocolate From Vicks VapoRub. Maybe That’s Not So Bad.
By Jason Feifer
From across the apartment, my girlfriend smelled smoke. “Is something burning?” she called to me in the kitchen. No, everything’s fine, I yelled back. A few minutes later, she came in to investigate. She found me washing dishes, oblivious to the smoking George Foreman grill beside me. “You’re so dying in a fire,” she said as she yanked the plug from the wall.
I don’t know why I didn’t see the smoke, but there was good reason I didn’t smell it. Like an estimated 14 million Americans, I suffer from smell loss. Like a smaller number of them, I can’t taste, either. I can occasionally appreciate a flower’s aroma or food’s flavor, but only vaguely and superficially. My imagination helps fill in the blanks; but when I’m blindfolded, I confuse mint ice cream and peanut butter ice cream. My girlfriend, who has the olfactory capabilities of a bloodhound, has run me through this test numerous times. She, like most everyone else I tell about this, simply cannot understand my experience.
I have a hard time explaining it myself. It’s as if my tongue and nose can sense differences – water tastes different from juice, say, and unscented air smells different from perfume – but the differences are faint and forgettable, and I have no ability to identify them. Chocolate is strawberry is scrambled eggs.
I’ve known about this for years, but have no idea when it started. After all, I never had a basis for comparison. Unlike someone with vision problems, I couldn’t simply put on glasses and see what I was missing.
In a way, I’m lucky. People who suddenly lose their sense of taste or smell after decades of trusting it can find the change so devastating that they fall into depression, lose weight or develop anorexia, according to Norman Mann, director of the Taste and Smell Center at the University of Connecticut Health Center in Farmington, Conn. I’ve experienced none of that. In fact, I’m untroubled by it – except that after the smoking-grill incident, I’m determined not to die in a fire. So I signed up as a patient at Mann’s center and went through a battery of tests during three appointments in September.
The center is one of a few specialized taste and smell clinics across the country, including one on MacArthur Boulevard in the District. Their task is not easy. Chemosensory disorders come in numerous forms, each with its distinctive Greek tag: absent (anosmia for smell; ageusia for taste) , diminished (hyposmia/hypogeusia), distorted (dysosmia/dysgeusia), altered (aliageusia) and phantom smells and tastes (phantosmia/phantogeusia). And because malfunctions can be caused by a wide range of problems – from chemical exposure to brain tumors to even seemingly unrelated things like Alzheimer’s disease – the clinics subject patients to a host of tests in search of the problem’s origin.
In this multidisciplinary approach, a patient may see a dentist, neurologist and otolaryngologist (ear, nose and throat doctor), undergo a general physical examination and even receive an MRI scan. The tests run about $2,500 at UConn and are usually covered by major insurers.
Some patients are referred by doctors; others stumble across smell centers on the Internet after having had their problems shrugged off by clinicians who do not know how to treat them or do not believe they are serious.
“They don’t know what to do, they don’t know where to go,” said Robert Henkin, director of the Taste and Smell Clinic in Washington. At UConn, Mann has had patients break down and hug him.
For some patients, though, sympathy is all they’ll get. When smell and taste loss can be linked to a problem such as acid reflux or diabetes, treatment of that condition may restore the senses. However, if the loss resulted from olfactory-nerve damage caused by head trauma or a viral infection such as a cold, there is no reliable cure, said Barry Davis, director of the taste and smell program at the National Institute on Deafness and Other Communication Disorders, part of the National Institutes of Health. Sometimes the nerves will regenerate and senses will be restored, and other times they won’t.
“I expect that taste and smell clinics are frustrated to a certain degree, in the sense that they see people they cannot help,” Davis said. “They can’t give them bypass surgery, they can’t give them antibiotics, they can’t give them some magic bullet. All they can do is tell them the extent of their problems and say, ‘Sorry.’ “
Sometimes, patients come in complaining of a loss of taste, but only suffer a loss of smell, according to Henkin. They confuse the two because taste is so dependent upon smell. Then, too, olfactory nerves do not regenerate as quickly or effectively as taste cells do, and they are more delicate and open to exposure. “You can close your mouth. You can’t really close your nose,” Henkin said.
When food is chewed, odors go to the back of the mouth, where a properly functioning olfactory system translates them into flavor. When the system malfunctions, taste often remains intact – that is, the mouth can still distinguish among sweet, salty, sour and bitter. (It can also appreciate temperature and texture.) What’s missing is flavor – that sense that lets you savor a lemon drop as lemony, salsa as tangy, ice cream as not just sweet and cold but mint chocolate chip or pistachio. Many patients who complain of a loss of taste are really just experiencing a loss of flavor, and can sense the four categories of taste just fine, Henkin said.
This is what we established on my first visit to the UConn clinic, where I spent two hours smelling bottles of diluted alcohol, trying to identify canned scents, and swishing dozens of liquids around in my mouth to rank them by their taste. The scents were a failure: Of all those placed before me, I could recognize only Vicks VapoRub. Now, that’s depressing. Imagine if everything you smelled could only be categorized as either “Vicks” or “not Vicks.”
The liquids, however, were more promising. I could generally tell the difference among them, although they tasted weak and I continually confused bitter with sour. I was later told that one of my problems is hypogeusia (pronounced hypo-GOO-zee-uh) – or diminished taste. That may explain why, in college, I put melted M&Ms in my grilled cheese sandwiches.
When I’m at restaurants, friends sometimes ask me why I order what I do.
After all, if I can’t really taste food, why do I care? There are a few reasons. For one, I have to order something. No waiter has ever said to me, “We’ll make you a tasteless meal because you can’t appreciate our menu.” And although my preferences may be based on habit, they are real preferences. I enjoy food on my own terms – the texture, the modicum of flavor I can mentally expand upon – and never really focus on how I’m experiencing it differently from the people around me.
When people say they pity me, I tend to go lowbrow: At least I can’t smell farts, I joke. But in fact, my loss of smell may have helped define who I am. I became a vegetarian at 13, long before anyone else I knew had done it, and never fell victim to the cravings that undo some others’ resolve. I like to think my experience taught me to follow my convictions, although now I suspect success came too easily. A steak, to me, might as well have been soy.
On my second visit to UConn, I saw dentist Joseph D’Ambrosio, who checked for signs that my problem was mouth-based. Abnormal saliva production, such as saliva that is too thick or in short supply, can trigger taste loss because saliva is needed to disperse taste stimulants to the taste buds. Inflammation or infection inside the mouth can also be to blame, reducing blood flow to the tongue and thereby damaging cell receptors. My mouth was fine, though.
D’Ambrosio said visible signs of trouble in the mouth are often linked to more aggravating chemosensory problems, such as burning mouth syndrome or distorted taste. Patients may complain of smelling or tasting metal even when they’re not sniffing or eating anything. Washington’s Henkin said he recently treated a woman who described her experience as like having a dead mouse in her nose.
With an oral problem ruled out, my third visit began with the nose. I saw otolaryngologist Denis Lafreniere, who checked for any abnormalities that could lead to smell problems. Common causes include tumors or inflammations in the nasal canal, which can obstruct the flow of odors. They can be treated with corticosteroids, after which smell commonly returns. Lafreniere stuck a long, fiber optic telescope up my nose – a uniquely unpleasant sensation – but reported nothing overly troublesome. He did find that I have a deviated septum – meaning the cartilage dividing my nostrils is off-center – but he said that by itself does not cause smell loss.
So it was on to the final stop: Norman Mann, the director of the clinic. He gave me a full physical exam, because he said he sometimes discovers undiagnosed problems that cause taste and smell loss. He’s found diabetes in patients, and some who come to him learn their loss of senses is the first symptom of oncoming Alzheimer’s or Parkinson’s disease, he said. (For other elderly patients, the sensory loss is more natural. Smell and taste diminish with age.) With me, though, there was nothing noteworthy.
That leaves two possible diagnoses, he said. I have a slight loss of taste and a significant loss of smell, and that’s either because of a long-gone viral infection or because I was born with a defective olfactory system. The latter is unlikely, he said, because congenital loss is usually absolute, and I still have some semblance of smell. If it was a virus, he said, there’s only a minuscule chance the senses will return. Damaged olfactory nerves can regenerate, but they usually do so within a year of the smell loss. “If we see a patient who has loss of smell for two or three years, the prognosis is poor,” he said.
There is some hope: “We see strange things once in a while,” Mann said, including a man who regained his senses after seven years. Instead of holding out for that, he said, my best bet is to buy a gas detector and make sure the batteries in my smoke alarm are good. I may not smell things, but I still can avoid a fiery death.
As I went through this process, my friends joked about all the unfortunate outcomes that could result from a renewed sense of taste. What if I discovered I hate the foods I thought I like? Or what if I become so enamored with food that I ballooned in weight? (Mann said he’s heard of the second happening, but not the first.) Instead, though, all this talk made me consider for the first time what it would be like to really smell and taste – only to be more aware of what I’ll always be missing.
But then again, it’s not so bad. I can always go to a concert and not smell the sweaty people around me. I don’t mind talking to someone who has bad breath. And if I still wanted to put chocolate in grilled cheese sandwiches, nothing would stop me.
Doctors Get Better Sense of Smell Disorders
By Kim Norris
The smell of coffee, frequently celebrated as one of life’s most pleasurable experiences, even by people who don’t like the taste – nauseates Kathy Kurland.
“Coffee is the worst smell. ... I can’t even describe it,” she says.
Other smells, such as freshly made popcorn, used to make her physically ill. Now, thanks to medication, she can tolerate it.
Kurland has a range of olfactory disorders that block some smells, turn innocuous or pleasant smells offensive and produce phantom smells that can last for days.
Kurland says a chemical caused the condition. It started about three years ago and got progressively worse. “I thought I was going to have to live in Alaska by myself, where there were no smells,” says the “fortysomething” Farmington Hills, Mich., resident.
Her condition is not imagined or psychological. It’s real. It has a name and a growing cadre of doctors and researchers devoted to it.
There are support groups to help people like Kurland – those who have lost their ability to smell, a condition known as anosmia; those whose sense of smell is distorted, called parosmia, and those who smell things that aren’t there, phantosmia.
Kurland’s research led her to one doctor who prescribed a medicine that made the condition manageable, but it hasn’t eliminated it.
When organisms first swam in the primordial sea, the ability to smell chemicals is what kept them alive. Smell is the first bond between baby and mother. A scent can transport us to a place or time, draw us in or warn us of danger.
Yet of the five senses, smell is the least studied and least understood.
“It was ignored for many years by the medical community,” says Beverly Cowart, a psychologist who runs a clinic for the Monell Chemical Senses Center in Philadelphia, the first such institution to study the senses of smell and taste. “There are a lot more people out there who have these problems than we previously thought.”
An estimated 14 million Americans have olfactory dysfunction including hypernosmia, a heightened sensitivity to scents. As many as half the people older than 65 and three-fourths of those older than 80 have a reduced ability to smell.
Many things lead to smell loss or dysfunction – chronic sinus disease, chemotherapy, chemicals, medications and head injuries. But researchers are not sure precisely what causes the condition because of the unique function and location of the olfactory nerve cells that transmit information to the brain.
“Most of the time there is tissue damage,” says Nancy Rawson, a cellular neurobiologist with the Monell Center.
Olfactory tissue regenerates throughout a person’s life. However, when the sense of smell malfunctions, it usually is impossible to tell whether the tissue is so damaged it can’t repair itself or something else is preventing cells from working properly, Rawson says.
“There is no way to see nerve damage without a biopsy,” she says. And “there is no effective, noninvasive way to record nerve activity” in the olfactory system. Putting probes up the nose to detect signals doesn’t work because the probes detect signals from the irritation system, which is separate from the olfactory system. That explains why people who can’t smell still have allergic reactions.
Rawson has been studying the olfactory system since 1991. She was attracted by the implications the regenerative powers of olfactory receptor cells could have for Alzheimer’s disease, strokes and other conditions that affect the brain. Olfactory receptor cells are the only nerve cells connected to the brain directly.
Losing the ability to smell could have far-reaching implications that are just beginning to be explored. The most obvious consequence is the effect on the ability to taste. Although it is a separate sense, taste is irrevocably linked to smell. About 90 percent of taste comes from smell.
When you consider the role food plays in our society, you begin to understand how not being able to taste can be a disadvantage.
“Patients talk about going to Thanksgiving dinner and feeling like they’re in plastic bubbles,” says Dr. Alan Hirsch, a neurologist who founded the Smell and Taste Research Institute in Chicago. “They can’t smell the scents of cooking, and everything tastes like Styrofoam. It’s depressing.”
“In the beginning, I couldn’t tolerate being in a restaurant,” says Kurland. She went to see Hirsch in March 2003, when her condition had become almost unbearable.
“On my first visit to Dr. Hirsch, I didn’t do any sightseeing in Chicago because I couldn’t stand the smells.”
Beyond affecting the ability to taste, the sense of smell is thought to play a pivotal role in people’s physical, emotional and psychological well-being and quality of life. Everything from body weight, to sexual arousal to the ability to sense danger is affected by smell.
Hirsch, who is a psychiatrist, too, is intrigued by the connection between the sense of smell and the psyche. Because the sense of smell is derived from the same area of the brain as emotions, he speculates there could be a link between the loss of smell and depression. He sees it frequently in patients who have smelling disorders. Of course, he recognizes that having the disorder can lead to depression.
What about recovery?
Smelling disorder recovery rates aren’t high, but recovery can occur, sometimes years later. The improvement can be gradual or sudden.
“We’ve seen recovery in people up to five years,” Hirsch says.
People suffering from anosmia or parosmia learn quickly that there is little consensus about treatment, and the options are limited to begin with.
To the extent that Kurland has experienced relief, it’s thanks to Hirsch. After he conducted his usual exhaustive exam consisting of extensive questions, a physical and hours of smelling exercises, he prescribed Clonazepam, a drug commonly used to prevent seizures. Kurland says her condition improved enough to allow her to lead a relatively normal life
At one time, the only foods she could tolerate were milk, white bread and cereal. Now she is able to eat most foods, although she can’t taste much of it.
Still, she says: “I prefer to eat at home. I don’t go out that much the way I used to.”
Frequently, Hirsch prescribes Cerefolin, a vitamin B12 medication that’s often prescribed for Alzheimer’s patients. The theory is that it works by boosting the ability of the remaining undamaged nerve cells. But no one is entirely sure.
Cowart of the Monell Center says the only form of anosmia that can be treated is caused by nasal sinus disease, and even that treatment is iffy. Steroids are effective in treating the inflammation chronic sinus disease causes, but they can’t be used long-term, she says.
“It has been a little frustrating that we haven’t found more treatment,” she says.
Rawson says researchers have had success with vitamin A, when it’s administered to lab mice immediately after their olfactory nerves are cut, but there’s no parallel experience with humans. Researchers also found that if one side of a mouse’s nose is closed off, the receptor cells die from disuse.
“So it may help to exercise [nerve cells],” she says.
The issue is getting more attention, thanks partly to the work of researches Richard Axel and Linda Buck. They were awarded the Noble Prize in 2004 for their work in mapping how the human sense of smell works.
Axel and Buck published their findings on the molecular basis of smell in 1991. Before that, little was known about how people are able to recognize and remember 10,000 or more odors. Although the findings shed light on the way odors travel from receptors in the nose to the brain, there is much more research to be done on how smells can affect humans, Axel said in a recent interview with the Associated Press.
“What many studying the brain would like to understand is how the outside world ... can be represented in the brain, which is simply a collection of neurons,” Axel says. “Our efforts, combined with the efforts in other fields, are beginning to allow us to take apart this very, very, complicated question of how the world is represented in the brain.”
Scent and Sensibility
By Suzy Banks
Gym shoes, chemical plants, and dirty diapers don’t bother me in the least. As a proud anosmic – a person who can’t smell – I’ve turned my defect into my greatest parlor trick.
When I was in the sixth grade, my sister, a couple of friends, and I each bought a little bottle of scented oil for about two bucks at the mall. In the car on the way home, we were passing them around and taking turns sniffing them. Though I suspect now that none of them smelled fabulous, Mom and Dad managed to mumble polite stuff like “Oh. Patchouli, right? Won’t take much of this.” “Mmm, very flowery. Special occasions only.” Then they got a nose-load of mine. Dad gagged, Mom rolled down the window, and everyone else ughed repeatedly. Mom screwed the cap back on my bottle and told me to put it as far in the back of the station wagon as possible.
I was hurt, but it finally got me thinking. How come I didn’t know that my bright-pink bubble gum-scented perfume smelled different from the others? Or, for that matter, different from Pledge or cat urine? As long as I was on this line of questioning, I asked myself why I never smelled the cinnamon toast blazing away under the broiler when I was in the kitchen, even though my sister could smell it from upstairs. How come it never bothered me if some boy threw an old, dead fish on me? Why didn’t I have to hold my nose when we drove by the petrochemical plants? That’s when it hit me: I couldn’t smell. I realized I’d probably been born this way, which made me kind of like that amazing Helen Keller, didn’t it? All this time I’d thought I just wasn’t paying attention or was too stupid to learn how to smell. Now I knew it wasn’t my fault. What a relief!
Instead of being a liability, my congenital defect, known as anosmia, became my best parlor trick, a welcomed alternative to stuffing my fist in my mouth. It was and continues to be a guaranteed conversation starter: You could never smell anything? Nope, nuthin’, not even when my mom was complaining about how stinky my sister’s goats were until she discovered it was me, wafting away beside her, or when my dad was searching high and low for a dead rat in our walls that turned out to be my gym shoes. How do you know you can’t smell? Well, maybe I can, and everything just smells the same. You can smell this, can’t you? (Whereupon a foot, a baby’s bottom, or a gardenia is waved under my nose.) No. What about your sense of taste? Just fine, I think, since true taste – salty, sweet, sour, and bitter – is generally the domain of the tongue and its taste buds. Flavors like basil and nutmeg, however, mean nothing to me. Ditto for spoiled milk, judging from the number of times I’ve sleepily consumed half a bowl of Raisin Bran before wondering where the little white marshmallow things came from.
And I never tire of the questions. The attention more than compensates for the dangers and neuroses triggered by anosmia. Sure, I wish I had a lottery ticket for every charcoal-briquette cookie I’ve baked, and no amount of therapy is going to cure me of my phobia of lighting pilots. But I muddle through, sticking my clothes under my longsuffering husband’s nose to see if washing is needed, throwing out lunch meat before the use-by date, and choosing my fine wines by the picture on the label. (I like animals, preferably a group of mammals.) Despite the difficulty of describing odors without referring to other odors or flavors (go on, try it), on rare occasions I enjoy a vicarious olfactory kick thanks to writers like Diane Ackerman, who, in A Natural History of the Senses, depicts the powers of a vanilla bean in a way that makes complete sense to me: “Its aroma gives the room a kind of stature, the smell of an exotic crossroads where outlandish foods aren’t the only mysteries.”
I tried only once to get to the bottom of my anosmia. When I told my parents I couldn’t smell, they took me to see a neurologist in Houston who held a couple of vials under my nose, became increasingly frustrated by my inability to guess their contents, and pronounced that, yes indeed, I couldn’t smell. Despite my strong feeling that this doc was nuts – decades later I can still picture him, slumped so far down in his office chair that he seemed to be sitting on his neck, his wide tie as filthy as a napkin in a rib joint – I couldn’t get mad at him for his ignorance. Back when I was a teenager, during the age of bloodletting and balancing humors, no one knew exactly how smell worked, much less how it didn’t.
The time may have come, however, to re-submit my nose to scrutiny. In the past 15 years or so, science has begun to shine the light of intellectual curiosity into the mysterious depths of the collective human nose. The Nobel committee upped the glamour quotient of digging around in noses considerably when it awarded the 2004 prize for physiology or medicine to Richard Axel and Linda Buck for their work mapping the olfactory system from a cellular to a molecular level. Alan Hirsch, the founder of the Smell and Taste Treatment and Research Foundation, in Chicago, who’s been probing noses for more than 25 years, recently unleashed a product called Timeless View, a scent that can make a woman seem up to six years younger to men. Of more practical interest to us anosmics may be the electronic nose developed by NASA that is sensitive enough to detect the difference between Pepsi and Coke, or the successful treatment of smell loss, discovered by Robert Henkin, of the Washington, D.C., Taste and Smell Clinic, using the asthma drug theophylline.
But I wonder if I would even want to be cured. What if I couldn’t stand the smell of my three beloved dogs, my husband, or, worse yet, beer? What if I became a wine snob or an aromatherapy addict? What if I cried out involuntarily the first time a stranger in an elevator let rip with one of those notorious Silent But Deadlies? But most important, if I were cured, how would I get attention, besides screaming in elevators? What would make me special?
Actually, ever since I discovered a slew of anosmia Web sites about a year ago, my feelings of specialness have disappeared anyway. Evidently, there are a bunch of us out there, between two and three million in North America alone. And, boy, do those of us born without a sense of smell share some eerily identical feelings and experiences. We all want a smelling-nose dog. We’ve all endured smell experiments conducted by siblings that invariably involved searing our mucus membranes with whiffs of straight ammonia. We all remark on the importance of texture in our food. (I’d rather eat car parts than boiled okra.) We also universally suffer paranoia (rooted in reality, in my case) about our own body odors.
For many of us, the fear of stinking outweighs any fear of death by smoke, gas leak, or spoiled food. At times, the social stress of not knowing if I have BO (the kind of stress that makes me sweat and, I worry, makes me stink and thus stresses me out even more in a self-fulfilling, olfactory version of a catch-22) has been so intense that I’ve considered chucking the Mennen Speed Stick and moving in with the Temiar people of Malaysia, who believe that personal stench is our “odor soul” and one of the six components people are made of.
Still, I’ve always tried to maintain a sense of humor about my condition, incessantly tossing out my corny one-liners, like “I can’t smell, but I can stink,” and startling strangers by sticking my nose in their armpits to prove my disability. But from the online postings, I’ve learned I’m about as lighthearted as Dick Cheney compared with some sunny-side anosmics who wrote:
“Changing diapers is like cleaning chocolate.”
“On occasion, it has occurred to me that a dead skunk in a box would be a good way to clear space in the computer lab in school.”
“I realized that I could be the ‘perfect girlfriend’ if I couldn’t smell stinky feet and farts.”
Ah, my people.
Such flippancy, however, is strictly limited to lifelong anosmics. Sure, we can get a little wistful when we think about never having smelled our child or baking bread or freshly cut grass, a few of the top wish-listed aromas, but those poor souls who have lost their sense of smell due to, say, head trauma, viral infections, or medications are nearly suicidal on the subject, their postings generally dissolving into heartbreaking pleas for cures. Evidently, if you know what you’re missing, you really miss it. And vice versa.
So in some ways I consider myself lucky, a smugness reinforced every time I drive by a feedlot or open a magazine packed with perfumed inserts or use a construction-site Port-A-Potty late in the day or dance cheek-to-cheek with a cologne-soaked gigolo or survive a packed flight from Denver on which bean burritos are served (true story).
And face it, all humans are olfactory slackers compared with the rest of the animal kingdom; dogs’ noses, for instance, are one thousand times more sensitive than ours (which does little to explain their fondness for cat poop). From this, some researchers have hypothesized that our species’ ability to smell is diminishing as that sense becomes less important for our survival. From this, I have concluded that my fellow congenital anosmics and I are therefore simply more highly evolved. No? Okay, then at least admit we were born better unequipped to sail through this stinky world, noses held high, in blissful oblivion.
The Scent of a Woman – Lost
By Anita Chang
January 5, 2006
NEW YORK (AP) – I spent a good part of Saturday morning over my bathroom sink, hand-washing clothes – scrubbing my cheery red sweaters and wringing out my Victoria’s Secret bras.
The clothes may or may not have been dirty. They might well have still smelled sunshine fresh. I wouldn’t know.
In August, I was hit by an SUV. I was crossing the street when it turned the corner and knocked me to the ground. When I fell, the back of my head hit the pavement and my brain smashed into the front of my skull. That’s where the olfactory nerves grow – down the front of your brain, behind your forehead.
Since that night, I haven’t been able to smell anything. Nothing.
It’s like living behind a film of Saran Wrap. I’m in a world where, if my eyes were closed, I wouldn’t know the difference between walking into a bakery and stepping into a gas-station bathroom.
I suppose I should consider myself lucky. My neurologist told me about an artist known for painting in vivid colors. After a brain injury, he could see only black and white. To cope, the artist would walk outside at night, when everything was reduced to those two colors.
After the accident, my parents immediately installed a natural-gas detector in my apartment. I have a gas stove; if it leaked, I would have no idea. I have to make sure my smoke alarm works, because I would sleep right through a fire.
That’s the obvious stuff. Other things I’ve had to figure out day by day.
Milk is tricky. How do you tell if it’s spoiled if you cant smell it? Out of habit, I still stick my nose into the crusty top of the bottle, trying to sniff out sourness. I hold it to the light. I shake the bottle, watching the milk slosh against the sides while I look for chunkiness. Usually, I end up pouring out the milk, just to be safe. Same with leftovers.
I like girly bath products that come in all those delicious scents. I ran out of body wash a couple months ago. As I stood in the bath aisle at Kmart, I wanted to cry. I used to open the top of every bottle to sniff the candy-colored contents. Now I go with qualities that don’t make you close your eyes and say mmmm – “For extra dry skin.” “With aloe vera.” “33 percent bonus.” Boring. I thought about switching to bar soap, but I don’t want to smell like a man.
Imagine the holidays without your sense of smell. On Thanksgiving, my brother cooked a huge spread and I missed out on the smells. Turkey skin sizzling to a perfect crispiness? Nothing. Jalapeno cornbread browning in the oven? Nothing. The savory yumminess of stuffing on the stove? Nope. My mom and I made mini pecan pies, and she wanted to use a block of cream cheese that was right around the expiration date. Smell it, she told me – see if it’s still good. Sometimes, my mom forgets.
I’ll tell you a secret. Not having my sense of smell has made kissing quite dull. What’s the point when you can’t smell aftershave/sweat/beer on a hunky boy? The excitement, the intimacy of knowing a person’s smell is gone. Why do we close our eyes when we kiss, anyway? Is it so we can focus on the way our partner smells, to give us something to remember later that night when we’re falling asleep? For me now, kissing is like eating theater popcorn without the butter. I KNOW I’m missing the best part.
When I tell people I can’t smell, many try to spin it positive. “Well, I guess you’ll be saving money on laundry! And cat litter!” Or, “Good thing! New York City stinks!” Truth is, I don’t save money on laundry, because I wash everything even if I could wear that sweater one more time. I change the cat litter more than I used to. True, I can’t smell trash ripening in the sun or fish guts at the seafood counter. But onions still make me cry.
The biggest side effect is that I’ve lost most of my sense of taste. I can only detect simple flavors. This Slurpee is sweet, but is it cherry or blueberry? That broth is salty, but I can’t tell if it’s chicken or beef.
This may be the hardest part. I love food. I’ve tried to cope with my new eating limitations, but it’s difficult for a glutton like me. I adore breakfast foods, but most have subtle flavors. Sometimes I forget: I take a big bite of a breakfast sandwich, expecting smoky sausage, spicy pepper and buttery biscuit.
The doctors say they don’t know if my sense of smell will return. Acupuncture didn’t help. Recovery from a brain injury can be as hard to predict as the weather on the day of an outdoor wedding.
But I haven’t given up hope. Every morning I wake up and stick my nose into the pillow, hoping to smell traces of my fruity conditioner. Nothing yet.
But that hasn’t stopped me from planning the awesome meal for when my sense of smell comes back: sea scallop ceviche, shrimp cocktail, stinky cheese, sweet potato fries, big fat ribeye (bone in, please, medium rare), mint chocolate chip ice cream and crème brulee.
Treat yourself to a happy smell today – gingerbread, expensive coffee, even
the top of a baby’s head. Sip from a glass of wine and enjoy the nuanced flavors.
I never, ever thought those simple pleasures could be taken away.
The Calgary Herald
February 3, 2006
Cold remedy blamed for smell loss: Company holds nose, settles suits
Imagine a world without the aroma of morning coffee or buttery popcorn.
Hundreds of people in the United States blame a common over-the-counter cold remedy for taking that joy from them: Zicam nasal gel, which is designed to ease symptoms and shorten the duration of colds.
Last month, Matrixx Initiatives Inc. of Phoenix, maker of the popular Zicam products for colds, flu, sinuses and allergies, agreed to pay $12 million to settle lawsuits involving 340 plaintiffs. The plaintiffs said they suffered anosmia, or smell loss, after using the zinc-based gel, which is put into the nose with a pump.
The firm admitted no wrongdoing and vowed to continue to “vigorously defend itself” in court. Sixty-one additional cases are pending, some involving
Zicam’s nasal swabs. The company’s sprays and lozenges are not at issue.
Robert J. Murphy, a spokesman for Matrixx, said the company had spent $12 million in legal fees since the first Zicam product-liability suit was filed about 21/2 years ago. He called the settlement, announced in the midst of cold season, “strictly a business decision.”
And business is good. Matrixx’s net sales rose 40 per cent to more than $46 million for the nine months ending Sept. 30, 2005, compared with the same period in 2004. The firm makes 22 products in the $3.5-billion retail cough and cold category and says its nasal gel is the only one on the market. Last year, Matrixx introduced a new, gentler spray tip to replace the pump.
Zicam products are widely considered “alternative,” and are classified by the Food and Drug Administration as homeopathic remedies. That means they can be marketed as drugs but are held to a lower standard for safety and effectiveness.
According to the FDA’s adverse-event database, 133 Zicam users reported having problems in 2004, the latest year available. Most involved the nasal gel and loss of smell, but because smell heavily influences taste, these people likely also suffered taste loss.
The Sunday Telegraph
February 12, 2006
By Bronwyn McNulty
Helen Ralston was 48 when she realised that her sense of smell wasnt what it used to be. I dont know how it happened. It just gradually came on and got worse and worse,” says Ralston, a retired senior administrative officer at Swinburne University of Technology in Melbourne.
I became very upset. Ive always been conscious of sense of smell-flowers, dirt, animals ... The worst thing was that I couldnt smell my own body. You dont know if your deodorants working. You dont know if youve worn your jumper once too often.”
While most people will experience a gradual dulling of their sense of smell from about the age of 70, losing it suddenly can lead to depression and even suicide, says associate professor Graham Bell, from the University of NSWs School of Medical Sciences, and managing director of E-Nose Pty Ltd (a company developing electronic nose” techniques to monitor pollution and use in medical diagnosis).
Some people are born without their sense of smell and they tend to not worry about it because theyve never had the sense built into their quality of life, he says. People who lose it halfway through life can become very disturbed.”
Fading of this sense can be dangerous, especially for the elderly, says Bell. Your nose gives crucial early warning of something starting to burn. Also, older people become very prone to food poisoning because they get forgetful, leave food out and then eat it.”
Of all the senses, smell is the most underrated. But life without it, Ralston says, is like living in black and white in a world of colour.”
If you cant smell, you cant taste properly. You have no access to your smell memories either, and you can become depressed.
The beauty of breathing disappears to some extent,” Bell says.
Theres evidence to suggest that sense of smell affects everything from mood and emotions to memory, libido, the immune and endocrine systems and even your choice of mate.
In fact, the human genome contains 347 olfactory genes, yet there are only four for vision, says professor Patrick Mac Leod, president of the Institute of Taste in France. The human sensory system for odours has attained maximum sensitivity,” he says.
Bell says that while its known that mammals such as mice and rats will choose mates based on smell, when it comes to humans sniffing out a potential partner, the jury is still out.
But common anecdotes suggest that if you dont like the smell of somebody, theres no way youre going to get cosy with them,” he says.
Smell can be partially compromised or disappear altogether. Sometimes it returns after a period of time.
The recovery process itself can cause a deviation in sense of smell, known as phantosmia, which makes everything smell disgusting.
That can last for years and can drive people to suicide,” Bell says. Fortunately for Helen Ralston, after more than a year of trying mainstream and alternative medicine, she hit on something that helped fix her problem.
I started taking selenium drops, and after about a week, everything began to improve,” she says.
Her sense of smell is now back to what it was before the loss.
When it came back I was thrilled. Its probably diminishing a bit now, because Im nearly 69, but thats normal.”
How can you lose your sense of smell?
Smell loss is very common after head injuries,” associate professor Graham Bell says. Nearly every head injury case involves a period of anosmia [loss of sense of smell]. Nasal polyps can cause it-any obstruction to the nose. Sometimes surgeons will give someone a nose job and it might damage some of the olfactory-sensitive cells.”
Chemicals can also damage olfactory nerves, as can diseases of the hormonal system, diseases of the nervous system, nose injuries and drugs such as amphetamines, cocaine, morphine and vasoconstrictors.
People working in the spray-painting business, subjected to solvents, have to be careful,” Bell says.
Old age is the other threat to our sense of smell.
After 80, most people dont have a normal sense of smell, with most of them not being able to smell well at all.”
The Philadelphia Inquirer
April 20, 2006
Smell the Roses, and be Grateful; Anosmics – Those without a Sense of Smell
– Miss Something Often Taken for Granted.
By Bryan David Finlayson
I was 13 when I lost my sense of smell.
Skateboarding downhill in Santa Barbara, Calif., my stepbrother Christian and I were racing. It was not important where we were going; there was no reward for winning, no punishment for losing.
We were competitive.
Gaining speed, I broke ahead of Christian, who was 17. I remember feeling elated over seizing the road from him.
Then the road disappeared.
Minutes passed before I came to, with Christian carrying me to the curb. My transition into the accident that turned my world upside down, for me, is seamless because I cannot remember. The fall was sudden, resulting in the direct impact of my head on the hard asphalt.
I was not wearing a helmet.
A week later, after I was released from the hospital, Christian described what he had seen.
When your head hit, your glasses went flying straight up, 10 feet in the air,” he said.
Doctors at the Santa Barbara Cottage Hospital told me that I had received a brain contusion, a more traumatic form of a concussion, involving bruised tissue. When the back side of my head hit the asphalt, the impact caused my brain to first bash into the back of my skull, then ricochet strongly against the front.
The ricochet did the damage.
There was extreme bleeding over my frontal lobe, there was the possibility of blood clots leading to seizures, and pressure was mounting inside my skull from the excess blood and swelling brain tissue.
They would have to drill if the pressure worsened, doctors said. I was given morphine and other medications to prevent seizures and reduce the swelling.
The medication worked, and the swelling subsided. They didnt have to drill.
Four days later, though dizzy and groggy, I went home from the hospital.
It was over a plate of spaghetti at dinner that I realized I couldnt smell the food. In fact, since leaving the hospital, I had not smelled anything.
My family dismissed my condition as temporary and said once I was off the anti-swelling medication my sense of smell would come back.
They were wrong.
Weeks later it hadnt come back. It has been eight years now, and I am still waiting.
My head injury left me with more lasting damage than I or anyone else in my family could have predicted.
After consulting a neurologist, I learned the violent ricocheting of my brain against my skull had severed the nerve endings connecting my olfactory glands to the lower cortex of my brain. I was not regaining my sense of smell because scar tissue had formed over the bone, blocking the nerves from regenerating.
I am among nearly 14 million Americans who are anosmics – people who have lost their sense of smell. For us, there is next to nothing in the way of medical treatment.
The medical community sees anosmia as a minor disability, like the common cold.
Generally, treatment is a choice between a biopsy or Cerefolin, a seizure medication.
Biopsy involves drilling into the skull. Noninvasive recovery with Cerefolin has been limited.
A reality of medical research is that smell is the most understudied and least understood of our five senses. The impact of losing your sense of smell on your physiological well-being is just beginning to be explored.
To an anosmic, there is no difference between smoky air in a pool hall and the fresh air outside, save for a lighter feeling on the skin.
I never smell the cologne or deodorant I apply to myself every day. I have no knowledge of the smell of my girlfriend. At the beach, I used to relish the salty smell of the ocean; now my skin just feels sticky.
Smell is a sentimental sense, and missing it can cause depression in anosmics.
Some of my fondest memories are smells: a rose, fresh-cut grass, the ocean. Smell is a valuable sense that is too often taken for granted and sorely missed when it is gone.
It is frustrating that there isnt more treatment for anosmia. For now, I must accept that I lost my sense of smell over nothing, a silly race down a hill in California leading nowhere in particular.
Thats what stinks.
Inside Bay Area
May 29, 2006
There is Help if You Can’t Smell the Roses When You Stop
By Virgil Williams and Ron Eisenberg
A surprisingly common problem is the loss of the sense of smell, which is estimated to affect 2 to 5 million Americans (1-2 percent of the population). To smell, odors must be breathed into the nose and carried up to the roof of the nose, where they stimulate the olfactory (smell) center in the brain. Any of several conditions that prevent odors from reaching this center will cause a loss of the sense of smell, which is termed anosmia.”
The sense of smell usually decreases somewhat as a person ages, but generally not to the extent of decreases in hearing and vision. Trauma to the forehead or back of the head can cause anosmia by damaging the nerves near the top of the nose.
About 30 percent of patients with post-traumatic loss of smell will regain this ability (almost always within the first year).Viruses, chemical burns (especially cleaning agents like ammonia) and certain psychiatric illnesses can cause anosmia, while irritants such as tobacco smoke can interfere with ones ability to smell.
Any impairment of breathing (nasal obstruction) can cause anosmia. This may be due to a structural abnormality (deviated nasal septum, or a crooked nose” or because of an inflammatory process. Both allergies (allergic rhinitis) and infections cause swelling of the lining of the nose and decrease the area through which air can flow. This causes the characteristic stuffy nose” that is felt by patients with allergic reactions to pollen or those who are suffering from the common cold. Allergic rhinitis may lead to the development of nasal polyps, growths that can cause obstruction of the breathing passages and result in anosmia.
An unusual cause for anosmia is a brain tumor extending into the nose or situated adjacent to the olfactory smell center.
A number of medications have been found useful in the treatment of patients with partial or complete loss of the sense of smell. Relief of nasal obstruction in patients with allergic or viral rhinitis can be obtained with decongestants and antihistamines. Antibiotics may be required if there is an infection of the adjacent sinuses. Relatively new medicines for controlling the symptoms of allergic rhinitis include both steroidal and non-steroidal nasal sprays. Although there are a variety of other nasal sprays available (such as Neo-Synephrine and Afrin), these are unfortunately addictive. If taken for more than two or three days, the individual may become dependent upon them, and therefore some doctors do not recommend their use for chronic problems.
Zinc and other trace metals occasionally are used to treat anosmia. Although evidence for their success is weak, they are essentially harmless in the doses prescribed and can be worth a try.
For the treatment of nasal obstruction and sinus disease, a relatively new technique is endoscopic sinus surgery. By passing a small tube through the nose, the surgeon can directly examine the interior of the nose and the openings of the sinuses. Abnormal and obstructive tissue can be cut away, and normal drainage through the sinuses can be restored. This surgical procedure often permits a return of the sense of smell, without leaving an external scar and with infrequent complications. Outcome studies have documented that the benefits of endoscopic sinus surgery are most dramatic in those patients who have substantial impairment.
People who have lost their sense of smell should observe some simple precautions
at home. You should always have smoke detectors, especially in the kitchen,
any room with a fireplace, and your bedroom. An electric stove is preferable
to a gas stove, unless it is equipped with an automatic pilot. If you use gas
heat, appropriate detectors are essential wherever a gas leak might occur. It
is also important to be very careful in preparing food, particularly leftovers,
since spoiled food that is undetected by its smell can be hazardous. When in
doubt, discard leftovers or have a family member with a normal sense of smell
confirm that the food is not spoiled.
November 16, 2006
Turning up our noses
By Lara Feigel
They havent got no noses
The fallen sons of Eve
Even the smell of roses
Is not what they supposes
But more than mind discloses
And more than men believe.
–GK Chesterton, The Song of Quoodle”
I plead guilty to Chestertons charge. Mine is a mediocre specimen of a post-lapsarian nose. As a fallen daughter of Eve – or, more accurately, a fallen granddaughter of a sharp-nosed chimpanzee – I am conscious of smell only a few times each day. I put on perfume in the morning, but because I use the same concoction every day and therefore suffer from what the perfumers call nasal fatigue,” I apply far more than I should, and end up fatiguing the noses of my fellow passengers on the train en route to work.
Occasionally I sniff the milk to see if its off, but more often I just glance at the sell-by date. Visual clues are more reliable than olfactory ones for a two-legged fallen human. On buses or tube trains, forced during rush hour into sardine-like proximity with a smelly person, I might – with due subtlety – shade my nose from the worst of his (or her) emissions. But for most of the day, it is unusual for me to notice any particular smells.
I do eat food, of course, but with the illusory impression that I am tasting rather than smelling the myriad different flavours that make up even an ordinary meal.
I am not alone in my olfactory bubble. We have been turning up our noses at smell for centuries. Some 2,000 years after Aristotle blithely labelled smell the most undistinguished of all our senses, Immanuel Kant denigrated it as the least rewarding and the most easily dispensable” of the five. He viewed it as more likely to bring disgust than pleasure and as, at best, a negative condition” of our wellbeing. In other words, we can use smell to avoid noxious air and rotting food. Kant, perhaps, would have been grateful for sell-by dates and the chance to abandon such an inferior sense altogether.
Predictably, it was left to the French to champion the sensual in a rationalist age. In 1754 Jean-Jacques Rousseau extolled smell as the sense of imagination” and his contemporary Jean-Francois Saint-Lambert lauded the nose for giving us the most immediate sensations” and a more immediate pleasure, more independent of the mind” than the eye.
A century later, French olfactory enthusiasm had seeped across the border into Germany, where in 1888 Friedrich Nietzsche somewhat bewilderingly announced: All my genius is in my nostrils.” Should we, like Nietzsche, be guided by our nostrils?
Whether or not they will kindle our imaginative genius, they might at least aid our physical survival. We no longer need to smell prey or predators, but there is evidence to suggest that we can use our sense of smell to recognise and avoid illness. In 1896 Gould and Pyle suggested in their medical handbook that lunatics could be identified by their smell: Fevre says the odour of the sweat of lunatics resembles that of yellow deer or mice... Burrows declares that in the absence of further evidence he would not hesitate to pronounce a person insane if he could perceive certain odours.”
A century of medical science later, some doctors still claim to be guided by the nose. Psychiatrists talk about an odour specific to schizophrenia and Lewis Goldfrank recently told the National Geographic that he uses his nose to make snap decisions in the emergency ward. Apparently the breath of a diabetic in coma smells sweet, and a whiff of garlic can signify arsenic poisoning. Specially trained dogs seem able to detect some cancers by examining the odours of a patients breath, and it is not beyond the realm of possibility that canine medical staff will pace the corridors of our future hospitals.
Perhaps our first step in raising ourselves from our fallen state should be simply to notice the ordinary smells that surround us. The people most vociferous in their praise of smell tend to be anosmics – people who have lost their olfactory powers. In the words of one anosmic man I spoke to: More than 24 years later, I deeply miss certain scents and smells. Life is lived rather like the boy in the bubble who suffered from total allergy. Many people have observed how fortunate I am to be unaware of the many unpleasant smells in our world; many people are ignorant fools. Without the constant reinforcement one forgets... the smell of flowers, of fresh cut grass, of a lover, of ones children, a glass of wine, a bonfire, the sea, the countryside after rain. The list is endless and timeless.”
It is important to bear in mind that losing ones sense of smell involves losing almost all of ones sense of taste. We are able actually to taste only six flavours: sweet, sour, salt, bitter, umami (richness) and astringent, and all tastes are a combination of these.
The sense of taste is comprised of 1m receptor cells, as compared with around 40m for smell, and the possible palette of smells is literally infinite. When we think we are tasting, we are usually smelling. This knowledge may help us appreciate the privations of the anosmic.
The literary champion of smell, more than Marcel Proust or Patrick Suskind, is Helen Keller. Growing up blind and deaf, Keller had to rely on her sense of smell for basic information about her surroundings, and found in the process that it became a source of intense pleasure. She lamented the fact that smell does not hold the high position it deserves among its sisters,” adding, I doubt if there is any sensation arising from sight more delightful than the odours which filter through sun-warmed, wind-tossed branches, or the tide of scents which swells, subsides, rises again wave on wave, filling the wide world with invisible sweetness.” She went so far as to claim that she could judge character by sniffing, and modern scientific studies have backed her up.
Generally, partners who like the smell of each others pheromones are more likely to get married than partners who dont. Perhaps we could teach ourselves to sniff out future irascible wives and slobbish husbands.
Reading Helen Keller, we can perhaps learn something of what life was like for our primate ancestors. In primitive animals the bulk of the brain was formed by the limbic lobe, which is still the locus for immediate sensations such as smell. Millennia of development in the brain have led to the reduction of the limbic lobe, which has become covered with cerebral cortex.
Humankind, even in its most primitive form, had a brain very similar to ours now, yet we have a much weaker sense of smell than our cave-dwelling ancestors. Indeed, congenital anosmia is on the increase, so the whole human race may be heading for an anosmic future.
Characteristically, Freud suggests that ancient psychosexual anxieties are behind this decline in our nasal capabilities. For him, it all began when man raised himself from the ground to walk on two feet, flashing his genitals to all and sundry. The shame of this sudden exposure, the theory goes, triggered a species-wide repression of the sense of smell. Humans found genitals less embarrassing when they were seen but not smelt. This meant that men were no longer able to smell menstruation or ovulation. Smell became less important in creating sexual excitement, and humans began to be turned on more by the look of each others bodies than the odour. As evidence for this view of smell as a forbidden, repressed sensation, Freud cites the fact that his hysterical patients often had extremely sensitive noses.
More recently, Michael Stoddart has rethought Freuds theory in more anthropological terms. Like Freud, Stoddart believes that when humans became bipedal, it ceased to be desirable for women to advertise menstruation and ovulation through smell signals. Stoddart, however, does not attribute this to a new sense of shame, but to the increased importance of the pair bond. Upright, earth-bound offspring-toddlers-needed more looking after than their more chimp-like predecessors. It was therefore no longer socially advantageous for the father to be tempted away from the family unit by the irresistible smells of his friends ovulating wives. The problem here, as Stoddart himself admits, is that evolution tends to fulfil the needs of the individual rather than of the community. It still seems useful for the individual male to be attracted to other women at reproductively auspicious times, just as it seems useful for his pair-bonded partner to have the attention – and seed – of other virile men.
Colourful as they are, both Freuds and Stoddarts theories have a somewhat tenuous logic. The most persuasive explanation of the decline in our nasal powers remains the most obvious: in a society where food is packaged and predators tend to attack from afar with bombs, smell has become relatively unimportant.
Despite the general decline in the human sense of smell, there are still many people in the world for whom smells are a continual source both of information and of pleasure. These people tend not to live in the west. In parts of the developing world, where food comes straight from the forest rather than the supermarket and is not wrapped in plastic, people rely on their noses to stay alive.
Unsurprisingly, some of these cultures privilege smell as a mystical, life-giving sense. For the Onge, who live in the Andaman islands in the south Pacific, smell provides the vital force in the universe. Onge people sign me” by pointing to their noses and greet each other with the question How is your nose?”
A reverence for smell can persist even in cultures where it is not necessary for survival. In both China and Japan, it still forms the basis for important rituals such as the tea ceremony, and in Japan people play a game called kodo, which involves identifying specific scents.
Some ordinary people can identify 2,500 different smells. Our lamentable sense of smell in the west seems to stem from laziness as well as evolution. The example of Helen Keller suggests that we could do better if we really needed to. One contemporary daughter of Eve whose nasal powers seem to have bucked the evolutionary trend is Evelyn Lauder, daughter-in-law of Estee Lauder and chief nose for the Lauder perfume industry. While pregnant with her second child, she awoke one morning to discover that her sense of smell had become peculiarly acute. Happily, this new-found sensitivity has endured beyond pregnancy, and, like Helen Keller (but unlike Kant), Lauder finds that her nose brings her more pleasure than pain.
When I spoke to her, she had just been to Central Park in New York to see” the spring flowers. But for her the experience was more about smelling than seeing. The whole air was perfumed with all the lilac bushes which were in bloom and my delight in going up there was to smell the exquisite aromas of all the various flowers.”
She is saddened by how little we notice smell in the west, and points out that our children tend to be more nasally driven than we are. Lauder temporarily doffs her perfume magnate hat to caution nursing mothers against wearing perfume or perfumed creams, as they can hamper the natural bonding process and even prevent the baby from recognising the mother. I find this rather unnerving. If perfume inhibits babies natural reactions to other peoples smells, surely adults are to some extent also affected – particularly adults with a sense of smell as precarious as ours.
It is strange that, in a culture so desensitised to smell, most women still wear perfume almost every day, and, according to Evelyn Lauder, about 50 new fragrances are produced each year. Two millennia ago, Pliny made the same observation, complaining about the time and money wasted on perfume given that the wearer doesnt even derive much pleasure from it him or herself. Several men Ive spoken to in the course of my research have bemoaned the way women cover up their natural smells of sweat and pheromones. One American man lamented his failure to find a vagina that really smells of vagina. He longs to bottle what he sees as the true scent of a woman.
In seeking to cover up our own pheromones and sexual secretions, we have traditionally turned to the pheromones of animals. Until recently, the majority of perfumers used musk and civet in their concoctions. Musk is produced in small quantities by young Himalayan musk deer during the mating season; the animal has to be killed in order to remove the small pod in which it is contained. Civet is scraped from the anal pouches of civet cats of both sexes: a disagreeable but not necessarily fatal procedure. Over the centuries, civet and musk have been sources both of delight and danger for perfume wearers. In 1688, Petrus Castellus extolled the wonders of civet for increasing sexual appetite, and in 1896 Gould and Pyle warned of the sticky predicament of a couple who over-indulged in musk.
Perfumers can now produce a synthetic copy of both musk and civet, and nobody in America or Europe uses actual animal secretions. Nevertheless, it seems anomalous that we go to such lengths to disguise our own pheromones, merely to replace them with the simulated pheromones of other animals. For Evelyn Lauder it is not a question of disguising, but rather of accessorising our natural smell: Women should have a wardrobe of fragrances, the way they have a wardrobe of clothing, the way they have a wardrobe of shoes.” She is adamant that perfumes complement rather than crush natural odours, and that each persons body chemistry makes the oils project differently. For her, perfume seems to be at once an aesthetic and a sensual pleasure, much like art or music. In this she resembles Coco Chanel, who also had an amazing sense of smell.
Lyall Watson, in his book Jacobsons Organ and the Remarkable Nature of Smell, points to some of the potential benefits of rescuing our most underrated sense from obscurity.” He suggests that with a little training we could smell which way the children went, who their friends are, who last used this chair or slept in that bed, and whether they were alone, when the girl next door ovulates and is likely to be attractive to or a threat to others, what our spouses had for lunch, and who they spent that time with, and whether or not we are going to need a lawyer.”
These are spectacular claims, and if Watsons imaginary sniffer existed, he would surpass Coco Chanel or Evelyn Lauder, and even Sherlock Holmes, the cohort of a more famous Watson. For Watson, the issue is not so much the sense of smell itself as the vomeronasal organs, commonly known as Jacobsons organs. These are small pits near the front of the nasal septum, about a centimetre and a half in from each nostril, just above the floor of the nose. They do not register ordinary odours. Instead, they respond to substances that have large molecules and no particular odour, including pheromones. It is Jacobsons organ, if trained well, that can help us smell a rat” or smell something fishy,” or smell whether someone weve just met is more likely to be a future enemy or a future spouse.
If smell is the sense of the imagination, then writers are the best placed to translate it into words. Yet writing about a sense as un-literary or indeed anti-literary as smell is surely one of the most difficult challenges a writer can undertake. One time-honoured way to write fragrantly is to use synaesthetic metaphors. The poet Martial starts out on this route with his smell of a silvery vineyard flowering with the first clusters of grass that a sheep has freshly cropped.” Do we smell the sheep, we might ask, or are they part of a visual image that is somehow equivalent to the smell?
Proust, of course, is the master of synaesthesia and extended metaphor. For him the countryside reverberates with odours so evocative that they assume human traits: smells lazy and punctual as a village clock, roving and settled, heedless and provident.” The scent of the hawthorn takes on the intensity of music: it has a rhythm which disposed the flowers here and there with a youthful light-heartedness.”
More recently, Thomas Pynchons description of breakfast in Gravitys Rainbow has undertones of Proust and of Martial. The musaceous odour of Breakfast” is flowery, permeating, surprising, more than the colour of winter sunlight.” Like Martial, Pynchon colours the smell.
Perhaps colour is one of the most effective ways of describing an odour: our reactions to both tend to be immediate and emotional. A new arrival on the synaesthetic literary scene is Luca Turin, a chemist whose chief contribution to olfactory science is his theory of how we smell. In The Secret of Scent, he rumbustiously dethrones the widely accepted notion that the smell of a molecule depends solely on its shape, asserting instead that the vibrations within the molecule play the crucial role.
However, Turin is motivated by more than just scientific curiosity in his search for the olfactory holy grail, and his perfume guide, Parfum, published in 1992 during a break from scientific pursuits, reads like a Proustian remembrance of fragrances past. Nombre Noir, for instance, is halfway between a rose and a violet” and glistening with a liquid freshness that made its colours glow like a stained-glass window.”
Turin believes that his edge in turning smell into language is due to the fact that for him smell has always had an utterly solid reality,” and he is astonished that others do not share this experience. For Turin, every perfume he has ever smelled has been like a movie, sound and vision.” While Prousts synaesthetic descriptions remain metaphorical, Turin seems genuinely to experience smell in several dimensions, and it is this that gives power to his writing.
Other writers strive to categorise smells, rather than to find emotional or visual analogues for them. Coleridge is being literal when he observes in his notebook that a dead dog smells like elderflowers. Similarly, the Depression-era novelist Thomas Wolfe conveys complex smells to the reader by itemising their component parts, listing odours that may be more familiar: He knew the good male smell of his fathers sitting room, of the smooth worn leather sofa, with the gaping horsehair rent, of the blistered varnished wood upon the hearth; of the heated calf skin bindings; of the flat moist plug of Apple tobacco.”
The most famous practitioner of this kind of writing is Patrick Suskind. In his 1985 novel Perfume, the smells of a baby are listed as warm stone, butter, and a pancake soaked in milk, while the smell of the most beautiful girl Grenouille has ever smelt is likened to a combination of silk and pastry soaked in honey-sweet milk. Like Wolfe, Suskind provides a disparate collection of familiar smells, allowing us to home in on the exact smell. Unlike Wolfe, though, he allows the synaesthetic to impinge on his smell-collage. The baby surely feels like warm stone as much as it smells like it, and the silk and the girl share a visual and tactile rather than an olfactory beauty.
It is clear that writers in ancient Rome, modernist France and postmodern America are tackling the same problem when writing about smell. And as you sniff your way across the centuries from Aristotle to the internet, you will notice how much continuity there is, not just in writing technique but in the smells themselves.
Catullus found hairy armpits as noisome as the Americans find them in France
today. The 17th-century poet Robert Herrick found Julias sweat as much
of a turn-on as Napoleon did Josephines 200 years later. (He famously
sent word from the thick of battle that she should abstain from washing now
that his return was nigh.) The American man longing to bottle vagina scent finds
his place at the end of this trajectory of secretion-loving men. In 1952 Le
Gros Clark suggested that Descartess cogito ergo sum should be changed
to olfacio ergo cogito. Proust, perhaps, would go so far as to change it to
olfacio ergo sum. Either seems a good endorsement for learning to smell. We
will never again be apes or know the exquisite aromas of a pre-lapsarian paradise.
This need not stop us from following Walter Hagens advice: Youre
only here for a short visit. Dont hurry, dont worry. And be sure
to smell the flowers along the way.”
Evening News (Edinburgh)
January 4, 2007
This sense is not to be sniffed at
By Julia Horton
A man born with an acute sense of smell is so intoxicated by the scent of a woman who he encounters one night that he accidentally murders her.
Unable to cope with losing her captivating essence forever, he becomes obsessed with trying to recreate her elusive aroma and embarks on a killing spree as he attempts to distil the fragrance of virginal female innocence.
The idea that a smell could be powerful enough to turn a man into a serial killer is the storyline of Tom Tykwers latest film Perfume: The Story of a Murderer, based on German writer Patrick Süskinds 1985 cult novel.
In real life, few people are inspired to commit such gruesome crimes simply by inhaling, but their sense of smell is far more important than many realise.
Because it is so automatic and ever present, it is often less obvious than other key senses like sight and hearing.
Yet it is crucial to peoples health and well-being, and can literally be a lifesaver in the most basic ways, as Edinburgh neurologist Dr Colin Mumford explains.
He says: Being able to smell is an important part of your day-to-day life. If you cannot smell when there is a fire you will not detect smoke, if you are cooking food and you cannot smell that it is rancid, you risk getting food poisoning.
Like taste, smell is known as a chemical sense, referring to the fact that smells, whether they be the natural scent of a newborn babys head or the artificial stink of cigarettes, are all essentially chemicals.
The mechanism for smell involves inhaling molecules through the nose where they trigger signals from the olfactory nerve to the brain via a bone called the cribiform plate.
The most common cause of loss of smell is a simple cold blocking the path of chemicals from nose to brain, but it can also be caused by head injuries, and in very rare cases, brain tumours.
Whatever the cause, loss of smell can be very distressing, even causing depression in some cases, because of the senses second main role, in helping people experience pleasure.
It is particularly important in eating, where it is often confused with taste, another chemical sense. Statistics suggest that some 90 per cent of what people think is taste is actually smell. Try chewing on a piece of fresh flat leaf parsley while holding your nosethe taste disappears.
Dr Mumford, who is based at the Western General Hospital and lectures at Edinburgh University, adds: Without smell, the joy of anticipating food is gone, and a lot of what people think is taste is also actually smell. Losing the ability to smell can be very distressing for people.
Permanent loss of smell is known as anosmia, and unlike loss of hearing or sight there are no aids such as glasses which can bring back the lost sense.
Generally the loss is temporary, a condition known as hyposmia, although when it returns it can create some strange experiences for people.
Fellow neurologist Dr Malcolm Macleod, who also lectures at Edinburgh University, says: In the same way that after an anaesthetic, feeling returns first as pins and needles before the person can differentiate between things like different temperatures, when smell returns at first people can experience unpleasant odours before the sense becomes more sophisticated again.
Experts believe that people learn to distinguish about 10,000 different smells which can influence mood, memory, emotions, the immune system and hormones.
At Cardiff University, biosciences lecturer Professor Tim Jacob has done extensive research into the sense of smell which he says has been shown to be present in babies as young as one day old, who give unhappy facial expressions when presented with unpleasant odours.
Alison MacColl, an Edinburgh perfume designer and aromatherapist at Ladies Love Fragrance, believes people do not realise how important their sense of smell is.
It is one of our most powerful senses but I think it is completely underestimated. It is never switched off, its run through subconscious control.
Temporary loss of smell is very common in women who use their own signature scent so often that they become so used to it their olefactory senses stop picking it up.
Thats why women will sometimes spray on more and more perfume because they cant smell it, while people around them are choking.
Heaven Scent Advice on How to Tackle the Problem of Body Odour
There is probably no greater social problem made by a persons smelland no other treated quite so flippantlyas body odour.
Perspiring is the bodys way of relieving heat and everyone sweats to some degree. Sweat itself has no odourit is the bacteria on our skin that feed on the protein-containing sweat which creates the odour-forming chemicals.
For some people, a quick rub with a deodorant stick isnt enough. And with BO being a big enough problem to affect professional, social and romantic relationships, why is it some people are affected more than others?
Edinburgh GP Ian McKee says: Body odour occurs because of the chemicals secreted by the body, which vary from person to person. Its why some have body odour and others dont.
Body odour generally only starts to become a problem at puberty, when our bodies begin to produce more of the hormone testosterone. This makes the glands produce more sweat.
Excessive sweating means more bacteria, so those who are overweight, exercising, anxious, or have thyroid disease, are more likely to suffer. BO, which commonly occurs on the armpits, feet and genitals because of the concentration of sweat glands in these areas, is treatable however.
Naturally, personal hygiene is a must, and a religious routine of thorough washing at least once a day using soap is essential to remove the sweat and reduce the number of bacteria that act upon it.
Antiperspirants and deodorants are also a vital after every shower. Ask your pharmacist for advice on stronger onesan antibacterial and antiseptic solution called chlorhexidine 0.05 per cent solution is available over the counter.
What you eat can also contribute to body odour. Some foods, such as curry, garlic and spices, contain smelly chemicals which are secreted out in sweat.
Its also crucial to wash your clothes in a hot wash and dry them properly. If clothes are left in a damp, warm state, any bacteria left will multiply.
If the problem persists, visit your doctor to get advice on prevention measures.
January 16, 2007
Olfaction disorders therapy; Studies in the area of olfaction disorders therapy reported from McGill University, Montreal Neurological Institute
Researchers detail in On the trigeminal percept of androstenone and its implications on the rate of specific anosmia, new data in olfaction disorders. Specific anosmia is a term that describes an inability to perceive a particular odorant in the context of an otherwise normal olfactory acuity. The most common example, for the odor of androstenone, has been ascribed a prevalence ranging from 2 to 45%, investigators in Montreal, Canada report.
In two experiments we sought to determine whether this wide range could be explained by the difference in steroid concentrations used, and by the degree to which the trigeminal system contributes to perception of androstenone. Experiment 1 demonstrated that high concentrations of androstenone stimulated the trigeminal system, as indicated by electrophysiological recordings. Experiment 2 demonstrated that conscious detection of androstenone is possible based solely on the trigeminal system. Interestingly, detection seems to interact with olfactory acuity in that subjects with a low olfactory sensitivity to androstenone were better able to detect its trigeminal component. The agreement between conscious experience and behavioral discrimination was not well calibrated, in that subjects demonstrated a clear overconfidence in their abilities. Altogether, the current study suggests that androstenone is an odorant that produces a concentration-dependent degree of trigeminal stimulation, wrote J.A. Boyle and colleagues, McGill University, Montreal Neurological Institute.
The researchers concluded: This trigeminal component explains the diversity of the reported prevalence of specific anosmia for androstenone and might have implications on future use of specific anosmia as a tool to understand odor processing.
Boyle and colleagues published their study in the Journal of Neurobiology (On the trigeminal percept of androstenone and its implications on the rate of specific anosmia. Journal of Neurobiology, 2006;66(13):1501-10).
For additional information, contact J.A. Boyle, Montreal Neurological Institute, McGill University, Montreal, Canada.
Red Deer Express (Alberta)
February 7, 2007
The Nose that Knows
By Dr. Dave Hepburn
My grandfathers name was Dah.
As a wee lad I would spend hours sitting on Dahs lap, watching the oft-resurrected Wyle E. Coyote rocket through another Acme disaster, while the burning embers from ol Dahs cigar would fall into his snowy white chest hair or directly onto my cornea.
Finally he would say, David, youre 15 years old. Get off my lap and give me back the cigar. I loved ol Dah and when he passed away it was for me a cruel joke.
Thirty years after his passing I received an unexpected phone call.
Hi, my name is Bugsy and I fought alongside your grandfather George in Italy.
As Bugsy went on to relate some of Dahs legendary military feats, which usually featured greased pigs, five aces or stolen jeeps, I began to notice a strange odor at my desk, stranger than normal.
I glared at the dog who glared back with a stupid yet innocent grin on his mug, but it wasnt him.
Suddenly this strange yet familiar smell twanged the memory cells of my brain. It was Dahs cigar.
Smelling a man dead 30 years may not be a great idea for a date, but in the part of my mind responsible for smell he was very much fresh and alive. Such is the power of the sense of smell.
Doc, I dont smell too good.
Well Bloggins, Ive got a cold so I really didnt notice...
No I mean I cant smell anything anymore. On occasion its a blessing but for the most part it drives me nuts. And when I eat I cant tell if Im eating the pizza or the cardboard box. Worse yet, its really getting me down. Life seems to have lost its zest for me lately.
At the roof of our nose, in a happy little bone called the cribriform plate, sits the olfactory bulb, an organ that is lined by kazillions of glomeruli.
These amazing specific smell files can detect, differentiate and process 10,000 different smells.
While taste buds have four basic tastes; salty, sweet, sour and Snickers, it is the sense of smell that allows us to identify exactly what it is that we have just placed in our mouth.
When an odor, nice or nasty, wafts into our nostrils, past assorted hairs, chalk and peas, the glomeruli processes the odor, packs up the information and fires it along the olfactory nerve to some place in the brain right next to the It-Wasnt-Me! denial centre.
Anosmia refers to the complete loss of smell. The commonest causes of anosmia include
1. Sinus disease (either allergic or infectious)
2. Upper respiratory infections, which is why normally evil tasting beasts such as Buckleys or Fishermans Friend can actually be tolerated when we have a cold.
3. Head trauma, which can disrupt the cribriform plate in the nose.
Half of those over age 60 have some olfactory dysfunction not necessarily related to any disease, unless you term aging as a disease.
As we age, our sense of smell joins the vision and hearing in a gradual decline.
Rather than young vibrant cells working hard in the olfactory center, old factory workers now go on strike.
Smoking helps to wear down the old factory workers even further. A lack of smell is associated with increased depression and a lower quality of life. Thus it can be concluded that smoking contributes to depression.
Astonishingly, loss of smell can also be an early marker for certain neurodegenerative diseases such as Parkinsons, Alzheimers and even Multiple Sclerosis.
In fact, anosmia may be the first symptom to signal the onset of these diseases.
Life Science Weekly
February 13, 2007
Olfaction Disorders; Study findings from Weizmann Institute of Science, Department of Molecular Genetics provide new insights into olfaction disorders
Researchers detail in Mutations in olfactory signal transduction genes are not a major cause of human congenital general anosmia, new data in olfaction disorders. Anosmia affects the western world population, mostly the elderly, reaching to 5% in subjects over the age of 45 years and strongly lowering their quality of life. A smaller minority (about 0.01%) is born without a sense of smell, afflicted with congenital general anosmia (CGA), researchers in Rehovot, Israel, report.
No causative genes for human CGA have been identified yet, except for some syndromic cases such as Kallman syndrome. In mice, however, deletion of any of the 3 main olfactory transduction components (guanidine triphosphate binding protein, adenylyl cyclase, and the cyclic adenosine monophosphate-gated channel) causes profound reduction of physiological responses to odorants. In an attempt to identify human CGA-related mutations, we performed whole-genome linkage analysis in affected families, but no significant linkage signals were observed, probably due to the small size of families analyzed. We further carried out direct mutation screening in the 3 main olfactory transduction genes in 64 unrelated anosmic individuals. No potentially causative mutations were identified, indicating that transduction gene variations underlie human CGA rarely and that mutations in other genes have to be identified, wrote E. Feldmesser and colleagues, Weizmann Institute of Science, Department of Molecular Genetics.
The researchers concluded: The screened genes were found to be under purifying selection, suggesting that they play a crucial functional role not only in olfaction but also potentially in additional pathways.
Feldmesser and colleagues published their study in Chemical Senses (Mutations in olfactory signal transduction genes are not a major cause of human congenital general anosmia. Chemical Senses, 2007;32(1):21-30).
For additional information, contact E. Feldmesser, Weizmann Institute of Science, Dept. of Molecular Genetics, Rehovot, Israel.
New Straits Times (Malaysia)
April 8, 2007
Off the scent
By Dr. Kuljit Singh
At a typical Asian cuisine outlet, everyone would be enjoying the aroma of
good food seeping through the doors of the kitchen. Imagine the feeling when
the food is served. When the sensation of smell is lost, it is comparable to
blindness and deafness. People who suffer from anosmia are unable to smell anything.
What is anosmia?
Wikipedia defines anosmia as lack of olfaction or a loss of the ability to smell. Many people may not realise they have this disorder until they encounter a situation whereby it is obvious that they had missed an odour or smell. It is distressing and could lead to depression in some. There is another condition called hyposmia where an individuals ability to smell is diminished. He would be able to catch the smell only when the odour/fragrance intensity is high.
How do we smell?
The earliest research on the mechanism of smell was done in 1756 by Linnaeus, a Swedish botanist. Decades later, scientists have differentiated various molecules and described them as aromatic, fragrant, repulsive, ethereal, resinous, spicy, burned, putrid and so on. Smell must be either in gaseous or volatile liquid form for it to be perceptible.
In the roof of our nose are sensitive nerve endings and nerve cells that form the olfactory system. These can detect odours in the air. The level of sensitivity varies from person to person. Some animals have greater sensitivity to the smell of certain odours. We even have canines that can sniff out pirated CDs.
Our system of smell is unique as sensitivity would diminish upon continuous exposure to a particular smell.
An odour can also mask another, especially if one is much stronger, or the combination of the two yields no odour at all.
There are 16 chemical elements that produce odour: Hydrogen, carbon, silicon, nitrogen, phosphorus, arsenic, antimony, bismuth, oxygen, sulphur, selenium, tellurium, fluorine, chlorine, bromine and iodine. Halogen and ozone are also odorous elements.
Losing the smell sensation
It is postulated that when air flow towards the roof of the nose is blocked, the sense of smell would decrease. This occurs commonly when we suffer viral influenza which causes an inflammation within the nose.
Patients with allergic rhinitis would suffer the same fate as there would be inflammation that almost occludes the air passage. It prevents air flow carrying molecules containing substances which could stimulate the sense of smell from reaching the olfactory nerve endings. Nasal polyps, deviated septum, tumours and deformed bones within the nose could also contribute to anosmia.
Medications such as nasal vasoconstrictors could lead to a permanent anosmia, scientifically known as rhinitis medicamentosa. It also causes crusting and bleeding. Treatment is far from successful in these cases.
Other probable causes of anosmia would be tumours of the nose or brain, head trauma and a variety of endocrine, nutritional, Alzheimers dementia, and nervous disorders.
It is difficult to promise recovery and total cure for anosmia. In some cases, if the probable cause is identified, the chance of regaining the sense of smell is encouraging.
The common treatment method would be to clear the offending obstruction in the nose. Inflammation caused by allergy or infection would be cleared with the use of nasal steroids and antibiotics. Polyps may have to be removed surgically if persistent, and other bony/cartilage deformities could be corrected.
Anosmic patients with nerve defects have less chance of recovery. Viral infections damage nerves and this is irreversible.
Hypothyroidism and poor control of diabetes mellitus may also slow down recovery of the olfactory system.
Nutritional deficits may be reversed with zinc, vitamin A, thiamine or any other specific nutrient that may be lacking. The evidence of its effectiveness is yet to be proven.
Many patients suffer anosmia due to unknown causes which are not amenable to specific treatment. Use of zinc sulphate is controversial as again, it has not been proven effective.
Other remedies such as vitamins and tricyclic antidepressants have been tested on some patients. It is advisable to eliminate toxins (eg. cigarette smoke, airborne pollutants).
Anosmia is not a life-threatening problem but it could be dangerous as sometimes poison fumes or the smell of fire are missed. This is common in many individuals and a proper nasal examination by an ENT surgeon would be warranted.
May 16, 2007
Rwanda; Olfactory Dysfunction; Common Problem Amongst Aged Patients
Most people recognize the values of olfactory function only after they have been lost. Olfactory function is important because it acts as a warning system which may alert individuals to poisonous fumes, leaking gases, and spoilt foods which are very dangerous to the individuals health.
Doctor Vennant Ntabomvura, a medical specialist in nasal related problems working at the university hospital of Butare, says that loss of olfactory function is a frequent problem amongst aged; however a few incidences may occur among the youth.
He says that while olfactory loss goes undetected in everyday life, it severely alters the quality of life of its victims.
The doctor explains that nasal issues can have a significant impact on our lives for example, when the sense of smell is lost, it does not only make difficulties in differentiating odours but also another sense is lost which alerts us to dangers from fire or other dangerous substances.
Three major causes of olfactory disorders are head injury, infections of the upper respiratory tract (URI), and sino-nasal disease. Other frequent causes include congenital anosmia or exposure to toxic substances, each of which has been reported to occur in less than 5 per cent of the cases.
Most people probably think that the enjoyment of what we eat or drink is most dearly missed when the sense of smell has been lost. Many patients complain to their physicians about disturbances of smell or taste and this is often explained to the fact that the olfactory loss appears to go unnoticed even in cases where there is head trauma caused by sudden olfactory loss.
Amongst the qualitative odour dysfunction are parosmia, also called troposmia which occurs in the presence of an odour, and phantosmia which refers to an olfactory perception when no odour source is present and they may occur intermittently or constantly. Parosmia is typically associated with reduced olfactory sensitivity.
The doctor says that almost none of parosmic patients reports to perceive pleasant odours, the large majority, if not all patients find these sensations to be unpleasant, sometimes even faecal. Also, signs of depression have been reported to be present in approximately two thirds of patients reporting qualitative olfactory dysfunction.
The doctor says that it is also important to know how the olfactory centres of the body work. For example the perception of certain flavour results from the interplay between three sensory systems of the olfactory nerve that mediates olfactory sensations such as the pleasant odour of vanillin or the rotten smell of an egg. Also important is the gustatory system that mediates basic tastes such as sweet, salty, sour, and bitter. Nerves that innervate olfactory and taste body parts also contributes to the state of sense of olfaction for an individual.
Major determinants of olfactory sensitivity are gender and age. It is well known that women outperform men in almost all aspects of olfactory sensitivity. Although the exact reason for this difference remains unclear, social, hormonal, and genetic factors are thought to be involved, other determinants of olfactory sensitivity include smoking which leads to a mild but significant decrease of olfactory function. This decrease has been shown to be related to the number of cigarettes smoked, but can be reversed after cigarette smoking has terminated.
It seems reasonable to assume that acute loss of olfactory function following trauma or viral infection is perceived as more severe compared to the gradual loss of olfactory function for example in sino- nasal disease.
In fact, signs of higher degree of depression or global psychological distress have been reported in patients with a more recent and sudden onset of anosmia. In fact, in patients with post-traumatic olfactory loss it is a characteristic that this deficit is only noted weeks or even months following the actual incident.
The doctor again explains that the epidemiological research in this area seems to be particularly difficult considering that, within the general population difficulties to adequately judge olfactory dysfunction are frequently found and consequently many patients would not seek professional advice, even if olfactory function was seriously compromised.
The possible treatment of olfactory dysfunction involves various therapeutic possibilities. Therapy has been proven to be effective only for olfactory dysfunction due to Sino nasal disease. Surgical therapy such as polypectomy, sinusotomy, and ethmoidectomy and systemic administration of corticosteroids are more helpful to the patient.
Dr. Ntabomvura advises that during evaluation steps, doctors have to consider the historical aspects of the patient such as demographics, eating, drinking and smoking habits. This helps the doctor to list major illnesses and injuries, medications taken in relation to symptom onset, history of present illness, endocrine information including questions regarding menstrual status or thyroid function is important.
Radiological evaluation may also be helpful to rule out the presence of olfactory meningeomas, pituitary tumours, frontal lobe gliomas, large aneurysmas and other cerebral tumours.
The Irish Times
July 17, 2007
I lost my sense of smell, and consequently my sense of taste, following a viral head cold. This has been going on for six months and there is no sign of it abating.
To distinguish flavours, the brain needs information about both smell and taste, communicated from taste buds in the mouth and nerves in the nose.
After the age of 50, a gradual diminution in taste and olfactory ability is common, with approximately 40 per cent of older people suffer from a reduction in their ability to smell (hyposmia).
Although the most common cause of loss of smell is head injury, anosmia (loss of smell) can be caused by a wide range of conditions including viral infections, sinusitis, dental abscesses or tumours. Radiation therapy for cancer of the head and neck can result in loss of smell or taste.
In a minority of sufferers, anosmia can be present from birth. A recent study found that 88 per cent of patients with post viral olfactory dysfunction (PVOD) had the Parainfluenza virus 3 strain in their nasal mucus compared with only 9 per cent of the control group.
The researchers suggest that this particular strain of influenza may be the cause of post viral olfactory problems.
I got the impression that my consultant considered this to be a minor inconvenience, which I can assure you it is not.
Im sorry if you felt your condition was trivialised; although not life-threatening, anosmia can impinge significantly on quality of life.
Not only is enjoyment from eating and drinking diminished, but there can be safety issues related to the condition if the sufferer is unable to smell dangerous gases or smoke from fires.
Ive tried various cures including herbal remedies, Chinese medicine, acupuncture and even hypnotism. Have you any other suggestions?
Unless a cause for the problem can be identified, there is no cure for the condition. If the problem is the result of irritation to the sinuses and nasal lining, steam inhalation, sprays and antibiotics may help. If you are on other medications, ask your doctor about the possibility of your loss of smell being a side effect of these, in which case he may change or discontinue the drug. There are claims zinc supplements speed up recovery from loss of smell, but I can find no research to substantiate this.
July 26, 2007
Police Officer Appeals Firing Discharged Over Loss of His Sense of Smell
By Carole Gilbert Brown
David Agostino isnt looking to be a trailblazer, but the discharged Collier policeman rapidly is becoming one.
First, he survived a motorcycle accident near Cleveland three years ago, then endured rehabilitation and recertification to win his job back, becoming one of only a handful of people to suffer a traumatic head injury and resume a career in law enforcement.
Mr. Agostino, 42, suffers from anosmia, a partial or total loss of the sense of smell, common after-effect of head trauma.
In March, Collier Commissioners unanimously voted to honorably discharge him because of this condition.
Mr. Agostino, disputes the townships position that his condition renders him unfit for duty. With an attorney provided by the Fraternal Order of Police, he appealed his discharge to the Civil Service Commission, which conducted a four-hour hearing last Thursday.
He later said that he was never offered an alternate position in the police department or a disability pension.
For its part, Collier cites a Collier Civil Service Commission regulation that says an officer may be removed for a physical disability that affects his ability to serve.
At the hearing, Timothy Barry, who represented the township, presented a February 2007 report from Dr. Carl Snyderman, a UPMC ear, nose and throat specialist who evaluated Mr. Agostino at Colliers request.
Dr. Snyderman found Mr. Agostinos anosmia to be complete and permanent, thus making him unable to smell the scent of alcohol on a drunk driver or to detect smoke, natural gas, or rotten food.
Mr. Agostino testified that he sometimes detects scents, but that the occurrences are brief and mild.
Collier ordered the olfactory test after former Chief Dan Rearick last fall received a report from police Officer Richard Lamb, then president of the Collier Township Police Association, who assisted Mr. Agostino after a high-speed chase on Interstate 79.
When Officer Lamb arrived on the scene, he said Mr. Agostino indicated there were no charges that could be filed against the driver. When Officer Lamb asked if the driver had been drinking, he said Mr. Agostino responded that he didnt know because You know I cant smell.
Officer Lamb subsequently determined that the driver was not incapacitated. Mr. Barry also introduced several other police responses by Mr. Agostino in which the ability to smell could have come into play, with FOP attorney Ronald Koerner pointing out that the incidents were handled with no difficulty or adverse consequences.
You can construct hypotheticals, but is this sufficient to terminate? he asked, adding he doesnt believe asnosmia is a fatal defect.
Before he was cleared to return to duty last summer, Mr. Agostino was given the okay from his own doctors, as well as physicians hired by the township. The Municipal Police Officers Education and Training Center , which sets the standards for police eligibility, specifies that incoming officers must undergo vision and hearing tests, but not smell. A sense of smell is not listed in the police job description, either.
All the attorneys at last weeks hearing, including Collier solicitor Charles Means and Civil Service Commission solicitor Jack Luke, agreed there is no case law of a police officer being terminated for inability to smell.
We were concerned that we may be in a situation out in the field that we would be unable to protect someone, Mr. Means testified. Also, if he doesnt have [smell] and someone gets hurt, were concerned he could be a target for a lawsuit or a claim. Just because there isnt [case law] doesnt take us out of the situation of risk.
But Mr. Koerner argued that there are other ways of noticing dangers, such as portable detection devices. His client testified that he compensates for his lack of olfactory ability by using common sense and evaluating clues at the scene, such as slurred speech, staggering gait, poor hand-eye coordination, drooling and glassy eyes.
Sense of smell is the last thing that I have ever used to determine whether a person is driving under the influence, Mr. Agostino said.
It is not clear whether anosmia is considered a disability, but Mr. Agostino, who is now working a job in security, said he qualifies for Americans With Disabilities Act designation because of his head trauma.
Mr. Agostino, who lives in South Fayette with his wife and three daughters, remains confident of his ability to be a cop. A licensed paramedic, he also hopes to be recertified in that field. Before being hired by Collier in 1998, he worked as a police officer in Castle Shannon and Baldwin Township.
After the meeting, he said he would be willing to use natural gas and smoke detectors, and pointed out that his situation is no different than a person who is working with a head cold or sinus infection. Smokers, too, often have diminished senses of smell.
I just want to do my job and support my family, he said.
Ellen Bond, of West View, Mr. Agostinos mother, said during a break in last weeks proceedings that she believes there is a stigma for head trauma victims. Two members of the Pittsburgh Area Brain Injury Alliance were at the hearing to provide support to Mr. Agostino and his family.
A decision from the Civil Service Commission is expected within 60 days.
Los Angeles Times
August 20, 2007
Hey, theres no sense missing what you cant smell
By Karen Ravn
I brought my three pugs to the vet the other day for their yearly checkup.
I was expecting compliments for keeping them in such good shape pugs can get a bit pudgy if given half a chance but what I heard was, Their teeth are very bad. They need cleaning. Some will have to come out.
Oh, no! I said. I had no idea.
Didnt you smell their breath? the vet asked.
No, I didnt.
I was born without a sense of smell. I cant smell roses or chocolate cake or sweaty socks or dogs bad breath. I cant smell anything at all (which means Im not exactly the target audience for scent marketers).
As far as anyone knows, congenital anosmia, as its called, is a rare condition. But its a hard condition to diagnose, so its hard to pin down exact numbers.
For a while I didnt know I had it. People would say, Ooh, I smell pizza! or Yuck! What died? I assumed smelling was one of those things Id understand when I got older.
For a longer while after that, I tried to keep my anosmia a secret. I knew it meant I was different. I was afraid it meant I was not too bright.
But these days I dont mind admitting it I figure it helps explain some other weird things about me.
At birth, I weighed 11 pounds. Or maybe it was 12. Apparently, I was an excellent eater before I was born back when I had to take whatever my mother gave me.
The minute I entered the world, though, I started turning my nose up at everything.
The pediatrician told my mother not to worry. Lots of babies are picky eaters, he said. But I was the worst, my mother said. The worst baby she had ever seen.
It was spring of my fifth-grade year. It was sunny and nice out, no smog, and a friend and I were walking down the street in our Southern California town. I dont remember now where we were going, but I remember what we were talking about. Orange blossoms. My friend was saying how good they smelled.
And I was agreeing. I was saying, I think orange blossoms are my very favorite smell.
But inside I was thinking, How does she do that? How does she smell orange blossoms?
For a little while, I had this theory. You know those hidden pictures ones where if you look at it one way, you see a vase, but if you look at it another way, you see two lovers kissing? I decided something like that was going on with smelling. I simply didnt know the trick. I just needed to learn the trick.
When no one was looking, Id try holding smelly things really close to my nose and then breathing in really deep. Once I even tried this with a piece of lutefisk. (You probably have to be Norwegian, like my father, to ever go to the trouble of eating lutefisk.)
But most of the time and this may seem strange I didnt think very much about not being able to smell.
This is how my mother found me out. When I was in high school, I used to go into my room and shut the door to do my homework, and from time to time not often, Im sure I would take a break from my homework to do other things. One day, for instance, I conducted a clever scientific experiment.
I brushed all the eraser shreds on my desk into a pile, and then I put the shreds on top of the light bulb in my lamp to see what would happen. What happened was the eraser shreds burned up.
It was a cool thing to watch, so I made some more eraser shreds and burned those up too.
I was in the middle of repeating the whole eraser-shredding scenario all over again when my mother stopped by to say Hi. What she ended up saying instead was, Whats that horrible smell?
What smell? I said, which was a big mistake.
I guess my room smelled like a junkyard full of burning tires. And apparently nobody would voluntarily sit in a room that smelled like that. Nobody normal.
After my mother found me out, she took me to the doctor. He tested me on various smells, and said yes, it was true, I couldnt smell any of them. And he said it was too bad, but there was nothing he could do for me.
But then he did do something for me. He explained how not having a sense of smell must affect my sense of taste.
Before that, I had no idea that anything was wrong with my sense of taste. I think Ive heard that some colorblind people dont know theyre colorblind until they get tested. They have no way of knowing what they cant see since they cant see it.
My taste buds function just fine. I can taste sweet and sour and bitter and salty and, presumably, umami, although I admit to not knowing what that is.
I assumed that what I tasted was all there was to taste. But apparently not. Since Ive been researching smell, various experts have told me that anywhere between 75% and 90% of flavor is smell.
This is good to know. But flavor is not my problem with food. My problem with food is partly with how it looks, and mostly with how it feels in my mouth. I would say that anywhere between 99% and 99.9% of all the foods in the world make me gag.
Spaghetti, lasagna, tacos, burritos, casseroles, cream-of-anything soup, salads, peaches, strawberries, artichokes, pie, omelets, mashed potatoes just about everything. Ive talked to lots of experts now, and Ive learned that many, if not most, congenital anosmics have a strange relationship with food. Very often, texture is the biggie, the be all and end all of whether a food can even be tolerated, just the way it is with me.
(In my little group of atypical people, Im really quite typical, it turns out.)
Being an anosmic isnt like being a lawyer or politician, but people do make anosmic jokes sometimes. When I was in graduate school, my roommate had a boyfriend who spent a lot of time at our apartment. He was a very nice person, which is why I think the following was a joke.
I was talking with him one day, and he asked about my non-sense of smell. Isnt that dangerous? What if theres a gas leak?
(By the way, he had a point. People who dont have a sense of smell have a greater chance than other people of being injured in a fire or getting sick from eating food thats gone bad.)
This fellow had a solution to the gas leak problem. Every time I entered a room, he suggested, I should light a match.
Ive also learned that not everyone can make as many allowances as anosmics this one, anyway tend to need. One time, I was at a restaurant with a guy I liked. The first time at a restaurant with anyone is always an ordeal, something to dread. In preparation, for several days Id been practicing a new way of swallowing food.
Id been practicing it on foods that I could eat anyway nice, dry foods. No point trying the nasty ones before I had to.
The technique involved getting the slimy gushy stuff straight to the back of my mouth and swallowing it without letting it touch the sides of my mouth, which meant, of course, not chewing it.
It was sort of like sticking a pill down a pugs throat, except I had to play both my part and the pugs part and I also had to look as if nothing unusual was going on.
That night I planned to try my new technique on the slimy, gushy food at this lovely Italian restaurant, my dates absolute favorite.
I managed to do it. Once.
Any more attempts, I decided, would be pushing my luck, so I fell back on the standby technique Id been practicing all my life, moving food around my plate strategically so it looks like theres less there than I started out with.
Perhaps I wasnt as good at that as I thought. The guy did not call back.
Not many people are born like me, but quite a few lose their sense of smell at some point temporarily because of a bad cold or permanently because of a head injury, viral infection or just age. (The good news about congenital anosmia? I have one less faculty to worry about losing.)
I think if Id had a sense of smell and then lost it, Id miss it. As it is, theres nothing to miss.
I do wish I knew what a smell is, though. Im very curious.
Los Angeles Times
LETTERS; She Has a Nose for Experiencing Life
Re the Aug. 20 article on congenital anosmia [Hey, Theres No Sense Missing What You Cant Smell], Karen Ravn described everything that I have gone through and everything that I have said to others to describe my condition.
I have suffered from congenital anosmia my entire life. I always wondered why things never smelled as good to me as they did to others. I finally got my answer when I went to a doctor at the age of 11 and they gave me a smell test. Thats how they determined that I was special.
As I grew older, I had to pay attention to my surroundings and count on others to smell items such as food and clothing for me. I also pay attention to the expiration dates on food.
I, too, base what I eat on color and texture. Something like a tomato is just disgusting to me since it is slimy and red.
I have never really had bad experiences suffering from this, just one scary one. I was home alone and I had a really bad headache. My friend came over to see how I was doing and she told me that my house smelled like gas. It turns out that there was a gas leak outside my house.
I purchased a natural-gas detector and feel much more safe with it in my home.
Since I cant stop and smell the roses, I tell others to do so, and to enjoy lifebut to include me. Just because I am different doesnt mean that I should be left out of experiences. Should that happen, I will simply drive my friends through Corona and lock my windows down and let them smell the sweetness of the cow manuremy sweet revenge.
Christina Lisa Grosman
October 11, 2007
Civil Service Appeal Denied for Officer Who Cant Smell
By Carole Brown
Colliers three-member Civil Service Commission voted unanimously last week to dismiss an appeal filed by a police officer who was honorably discharged in March because he lost his sense of smell.
David Agostino, 43, of South Fayette, has anosmia, or loss of olfactory function, as a result of an off-duty motorcycle accident in August 2004 in Ohio. The condition is a common after-effect of head trauma.
Mr. Agostino completed two years of rehabilitation and recertification to get his job back on Colliers police force in the summer of 2006. But other police officers soon noticed his inability to smell.
After a chase last fall on Interstate 79 of a driver suspected of drunk driving, an officer wrote a report to the former police chief raising concerns about Mr. Agostinos inability to smell alcohol. The driver in that case was found not to be under the influence and was not charged. Mr. Agostino said no one complained to him about his inability to smell or its impact on his work.
After he was terminated, Mr. Agostino filed an appeal, which led to a lengthy hearing in July. At the hearing, he disputed the townships position that his inability to smell impedes his performance, noting that his other senses compensate and also that portable equipment could be used to detect the presence of potentially dangerous odors.
He also said that he was never offered an alternative position in the police department.
Other testimony stressed police officers roles as first responders to incidents and the fear that Mr. Agostinos continued employment could pose a safety risk to others and expose the township to liability. In its opinion, the civil service commission stated that it, too, was not impressed with the opinion of Officer Agostino that he does not require a sense of smell to perform his duties.
The ruling also stated that testimony presented at the July hearing, as well as Mr. Agostinos failure to present anything more than a denial that his performance is compromised, was more than sufficient to warrant the actions taken by the Board of Commissioners.
The commission recognizes his past service and regrets it cant ignore his disability, Civil Service solicitor Jack Luke said when he read the decision.
He said the commission held two executive sessions to discuss the transcript from the July hearing.
Mr. Agostino and his Fraternal Order of Police attorney, Ronald Koerner, this week said they could not comment because they had not seen the civil service decision.
Before he returned to duty last summer, Mr. Agostino was given the okay from his own doctors, as well as physicians hired by the township. The state Municipal Police Officers Education and Training Center which sets standards for police eligibility, does not list a sense of smell as a job requirement.
Attorneys involved in the matter said they know of no other cases involving a police officer being terminated for inability to smell.
Mr. Agostino, who also has paramedic training, was hired as a Collier officer in 1998. He also has been a police officer in Castle Shannon and Baldwin Township.
He has 30 days to appeal the civil service decision to Allegheny County Common Pleas Court.
October 12, 2007
Not to be Sniffed at, the Sense that Opens Gateway to Memories
We underestimate the importance of our sense of smell, which is bound up with memories, happiness and wellbeing.
Try eating one of your favourite foods while holding your nose. Not such an enjoyable experience, is it?
Ask any woman who has had a baby what would be the first thing shed do when handed a newborn to cuddle. Chances are that shed dip her nose to draw in the fantastic warm aroma of the childs downy head... and then grow slightly misty-eyed at the memory of her own babes-in-arms.
Think back to early memories of mum, dad, home, your bed, messing around in the garden shed or your first school. Almost certainly your nostalgia will be laced with some of the following: perfume, soap, Brylcreem, flowers, floor polish, sizzling bacon, the scent of fresh laundry, bicycle oil, and maybe even the slightly cheesy pong of school milk.
Perhaps memories of your mother are still stirred up by the whiff of lavender, lilac or honeysuckle on a summer breeze, or the scent of freshly-baked bread or sponge cake. Are reminiscences about your father evoked by walking past someone who wears the same old-fashioned aftershave, or smelling Airfix glue?
Its not just the actual memories that are stirred up by smells. Smells can bring long-buried feelings flooding back to the surface. I know a woman who occasionally takes out her long-dead mothers mink stole and has a little sniff.... the whiff of distant freesia-laden perfume stirs up a mixture of happy memories and tearful longing.
Smells are associated with strong emotional feelings, says Tim Jacob, a cell physiologist at Cardiff Universitys School of Biosciences. Smells tend to stir up feelings from long ago, when we were youthful and more excitable. A smell that evokes feelings towards something particularly awful in our past can even, on rare occasions, bring on an epileptic fit.
Prof Jacob has done research that pinpoints the smells we are most prone to associate with our parents. Mothers are often brought to mind by fresh laundry, washing powder, perfume, cotton and freshly-baked bread.
Memories of our fathers are likely to be stirred up by leather, woodsmoke, soap, aftershavebut most of all by tobacco. A sign of the times. Strong feelings are experienced in connection with some smells because the primitive parts of our brain that govern memory and smell are right next to each other, with many interconnections that help to produce emotional responses were not necessarily aware are buried inside us.
When we smell a certain smell, we relive a memory and also the feelings we originally experienced. In ancient times, humans probably valued their nose for other reasons, such as its usefulness in telling the difference between good and bad fooda skill weve perhaps given up to the ritual of reading use by labels.
Among 1,000 adults questioned across the UK, the favourite smell was freshly-baked bread, although fish and chips also featured near the top of the list. Such aromas were associated by many with feelings of happiness, calmness and being loved.
The research was sponsored by manufacturers of a popular brand of air-freshener. In the great scheme of things, says Prof Jacob, his sort of investigation tends to be overlooked when large research grants are allocated. It relies instead on commercial sponsorship.
He says we underestimate the importance of our sense of smelland the debilitating effects experienced if our olfactory powers are temporarily suppressed or taken away permanently. This can happen through viral illness (like a heavy cold or respiratory tract infection), or head injury. Loss or partial loss of the sense of smell is known as anosmia.
When someone loses their sense of smell, there is only a 15-30 per cent chance of recovery. So closely is the sense of smell allied to enjoying food, drink and our environment that life can seem rather grey when it is taken away, says the professor.
Anosmics can become depressed and often either very thinthey lose interest in food because taste equals smell plus flavouror fat because they try to compensate by overdosing on sweet things in an effort to smell/taste anything at all.
As we go through our everyday lives, our noses are constantly sampling the world around us, and smell is part of the emotional background to life, says Prof Jacob. Take away the sense of smell, and your sex life is affected, you can become paranoid about your own body odour, and even agoraphobic because of anxiety about how you smell to others.
Unfortunately, not much can be done to help anosmics, although research is ongoing. Its amazing how many people dont realise that it is a recognised problem, and some doctors know little about it. It is still worth asking to be referred to an ear, nose and throat specialist, though.
So, going back to those memories prompted by a bar of soap or a cloud of cigar smoke: even if the feelings revisited are tinged with sadness, we should be pleased we are able to access them, thanks to our undervalued nose.
Mansfield News Journal (Ohio)
December 16, 2007
Sense of Smell Gone, but Memories Linger On
Oh Granny, this pizza smells delicious!
Mother, Im so glad youre still wearing Ambush perfume after all these years.
Lilacs are definitely the most beautiful smelling flowers in the world.
Hot buttered popcorn at the movie theater.
Brats cooking over an open fire.
Talc on a newborn baby.
Bayberry scented candleswhat a good idea!
Oh boy, I smell fresh waffles and hot syrup for breakfast.
Is that cloves simmering on the stove?
All joyous proclamations about beautiful scents!
Alas, to me these are but memories.
To put it quite bluntly, I cant smell a darn thing.
I have lost my sense of smell. The medical term is Anosmia. About two million Americans experience this loss permanently, while many of you may have noticed it temporarily during a bout with a bad cold.
My son-in-law informed me that losing your sense of smell is a normal part of aging. (He heard it on a morning news show.) A dismaying development. Losing your sense of smell can put you in danger. Have you ever walked away from a sandwich grilling on the stove and forgotten about it? That burning bread will remind you to get back in the kitchen, but only if you smell it. I didnt smell it, and when I did walk into the kitchen later I was surprised to see curls of black smoke going up from the griddle. Couldve started a fire, but I wouldnt have smelled that smoke either.
Suppose I hadnt walked away and then had a perfectly grilled cheese sandwich in front of me with some deliciously aromatic vegetable beef soup. Looks good, tastes good, but not smelling it takes away some of the pleasure of eating it.
On the other hand, burnt toast, Vicks Vaporub, and gas fumes no longer bother me. If youre a smoker, youre not allowed to smoke in my house. But if you puff right at me, I cant smell it.
When I was a young girl growing up in southern Illinois, my Grandma Mills had this charming picture hanging above her kitchen sink. (Her kitchen sink, by the way, consisted of a pump with a handle and a drain to the outdoors.) Life was rough in the depression years, but occasionally a thing of beauty was allowed. This picture print by H.G. Plumb showed five darling kittenseach one representing one of the five senses. I used to have them all named, but I forget their names now. Am I losing my sense of memory also? The kittens are frolicking on a ladys fancy dresser. They are having such fun. The little white one near the top is listening to the tick-tock of the clock. Her sister is gazing at her own image in a little mirror. Another sister appears to be tasting cold cream from a jar. Their black-and-white pal is touching a pair of leather gloves. The tiny tan-and-white friend is smelling the roses. A fanciful picture which Grandma used to teach five-year-old me about the five senses.
Unfortunately for me, when family items were dispersed, the original picture went to my sister. However, you can buy a nice print anywhere, and I have given one as a gift several times. You can even find it on greeting cards.
Hope things are still smelling good to you. Ill just enjoy my picture.
Cape Times (South Africa)
February 7, 2008
How Our Sense of Smell Helps Us Chart a Safe and Pleasant Course through Life
Anosmia refers to the inability to smell, the lack of olfactory activity. Hyposmia, on the other hand, refers to an increased ability to smell. It is as hard to imagine a world without smell, a curse of sorts, as it is to imagine living in a world of enhanced smell, in the sensory world of the dog, for example, a curse of sorts, too.
Anosmia can be temporary or permanent. A cold or sinusitis, or any upper respiratory tract infection, may temporarily deprive you of a sense of smell. It is more than likely, if not inevitable, that you would lose your sense of taste, too. Taste and smell are bound together, partners in a dance of sensory joy.
Salty, sour, sweet, bitter, umami (richness) and astringent (sharp or severe) are our six distinctive tastes, but we are able to smell about 10 000 scents that conspire with taste to give us the magic of flavour. When one cant smell anything, food loses most of its flavour (see olfaction at www.wikipedia.com).
A permanent loss of smell, hard to imagine as it is, will be caused by damage to any part of the olfactory pathway, which has three essential parts: the olfactory sensory neurons in the olfactory epithelium, the olfactory bulb, and the brains olfactory cortex. Damage to any part will cause a problem.
Damage to the system can occur at birth due to genetic factors, referred to as congenical anosmia. It could arise as a consequence of Parkinsons disease or Alzheimers. Environmental poisons, cigarette smoke or nasal sprays may also damage the smell receptors in the nose. And there is the nasal polyp.
Richard Axel and Linda Buck jointly received the Nobel Prize in physiology or medicine in 2004 for figuring out how smell works. Associated with the Howard Hughes Medical Institute, they cast serious light on what was considered to be a trivial medical problem. Today, it is taken more seriously.
Without smell, it is difficult to detect gas leaks, fire, body odour and spoiled or rotting food. Without smell, many, many memories, a central part of living in a world of meaning, cannot be retrieved from the brains system of neural cell memory. It may lead to a loss of libido and sexual interest, possibly impotence.
Still, scientists have established that up to 5% of the genes in the human genome spread over 21 chromosomes are coded for what is known as odorant receptors. That is a very, very significant number. It suggests that smell served many more functions in our distant pastand what may those be?
Smell is often viewed as an aesthetic sense among humans. Smell is, however, a primal sense. It is the sense that affords most organisms the ability to detect food, predators and mates.
Smell is therefore the central sense by which most organisms communicate with their environment.
We do not today go around sniffing out predators. We do not have to. Thankfully, the days of living in constant fear of attack and predation are no longer with us. But we still have the machinery to sniff predators out, albeit in an idle state. In time, evolutions natural selection might edit it out of our sensory repertoire.
While we may go around sniffing out good mates, it is not the best or even, in todays world of ubiquitous fragrance, a particularly viable strategy for choosing someone. Fragrance may blunt the work of that quite separate and special class of receptors to sniff out pheromones, chemicals that stimulate sexual desire.
Because smell is not about sex, contrary to popular belief, its about food and protection from decaying, poisonous things that can hurt you, to tell you whether whatever is in your hands is good for you, writes Chandler Burr in The Emperor of Scent.
What is a world without smell? A diminished world, certainly. A world where food no longer holds an allure or gives pleasure. A world where you can no longer smell geraniums or perfumes.
I suppose that the only thing that is worse is to smell a stink when its actually a fragrance, a disorder that must have a name.
So, every morning that we wake to the glorious gift of smell, we should say thank you, for it is hard to imagine a meaningful life without it.
Brains Olfactory Bulb Grows With Sense of Smell
The olfactory bulb in the brainthe brains smell centermay change in size as a persons sense of smell changes, a German study reports.
In this study, researchers at the University of Dresden Medical School studied 20 people with loss of sense of smell. At the start of the study, the patients underwent an assessment that included MRI of the brain and nasal endoscopy, an examination of the inside of the nose using a flexible instrument called an endoscope. Their ability to detect odors, discriminate between odors and identify particular odors was also tested. The full assessment was repeated 13 to 19 months later.
At the first assessment, seven of the 20 patients had no sense of smell (anosmia) and 13 had a reduced sense of smell (hyposmia). At the second assessment, six had anosmia and 14 had hyposmia, the study found.
In patients who initially had hyposmia, the volume of the olfactory bulb increased
as the patients sense of smell increased. But there was no correlation
between the volume of the olfactory bulb and the ability to distinguish between
or identify specific odors.
The study was published in the June issue of the journal Archives of Otolaryngology Head & Neck Surgery.
The correlation between olfactory bulb volume and olfactory function may potentially be used in combination with other factors influencing olfaction such as remaining olfactory function, age and duration of olfactory loss as a means to provide patients with individual information on the prognosis of their disease, the study authors wrote.
Hypothetically, a multifactorial approach could be applied to eventually come up with a formula that would allow a more precise prognosis of olfactory function. Especially since therapeutic options in patients with olfactory loss are limited, at present, this type of information is of high clinical significance.
March 26, 2009
Pa. court to officer: No sense of smell, no job
By Mark Scolforo
Police officers who lose their sense of smell also risk losing their jobs, a Pennsylvania appeals court ruled Thursday. A suburban Pittsburgh township had the right to terminate Officer David J. Agostino after he lost his sense of smell in an off-duty motorcycle accident, because officers must be able to detect drugs, alcohol, hazardous materials, natural gas and other substances, a three-judge Commonwealth Court panel ruled.
The evidence sufficiently demonstrated that Agostino suffered a physical disability that rendered him unfit to serve as a police officer, Judge Bernard L. McGinley wrote. Critically, Agostino frequently patrolled alone and served as a first responder in instances that required a sense of smell to ensure his safety and the safety of others.
Agostino, who joined the force in 1998, was seriously injured in the August 2004 accident. A physician testified that his anosmiathe medical term for lacking a sense of smellwas probably related to a head injury and was permanent.
The officer passed a physical and returned to duty nearly two years later, but his lack of smell soon became an issue.
The Collier Township Board of Commissioners discharged him on grounds that he had a physical disability affecting his duties, and the township civil service commission and an Allegheny County judge later upheld the decision.
Agostino insisted he was capable of performing police duties. He argued that a sense of smell is neither an essential function nor tested by the Pennsylvania Municipal Police Officers Education and Training Commission.
The township said Agostinos inability to smell impeded his performance. A fellow officer testified that Agostino was unable to smell the alcohol and marijuana odor around a motorist who had led police on a high-speed chase, McGinley wrote.
Collier Township Police Chief Thomas D. Devin reported that Agostino's condition became a problem during a call in which the officer helped an elderly resident restart a furnace.
Devin explained that Agostinos inability to smell if the furnace was leaking gas created a hazardous situation, placing Agostino, the resident and the public in danger because ‘it could have possibly caused an explosion, McGinley wrote.
Pennsylvania State Police Maj. John Gallaher, executive director of the state municipal officers training commission, said physicians who examine recruits are supposed to issue an opinion about fitness for duty. There are standards for vision, hearing and cardiovascular health, but not for smell.
There are many reasons a police officer would need to be able to smell, said Edward Mamet, a retired New York City Police captain who is a consultant on police practices. He said he once sniffed out a major gas leak, as well as the telltale yeast from an illegal still.
Where its dark, sometimes your sense of smell can help you, guide your way, he said. Theres the smell of death when a body turns what we call ripe after being dead for a few days. Its a horrible smell.
Collier Township solicitor Chuck Means said lawyers involved in the case could not find a legal precedent that directly addressed Agostinos situation. Larger departments, he noted, could assign someone who cant smell to duties in which safety would not be an issue.
In Collier Township the police officers are all out in the field and theyre first responders, Means said.
Agostinos lawyer, Ronald Koerner, said he was unsure whether he would appeal the ruling.
Im disappointed, but we'll have to see what were going to do, Koerner said.
New York Times
January 13, 2011
The Anosmia Case
After the financial meltdown, is it really possible a company argued at the Supreme Court that too much information for investors is as bad as too little?
Thats what Matrixx Initiatives did on Monday in a case about whether it should have disclosed complaints regarding Zicam, its homeopathic cold remedy. Twenty-three people claimed that they took Zicam and lost their sense of smell, a condition known as anosmia.
The case arose after ABCs Good Morning America aired a piece questioning Zicams safety. The price of Matrixxs stock fell 24 percent. Shareholders sued in a class action, saying Matrixx should have warned investors about the problems and related lawsuits.
The company claimed that it didnt have to, arguing that the complaints had no scientific basis, that any loss of smell should be blamed on illness and that the number of complaints was not statistically significant.
Justice Stephen Breyer seemed to surprise himself when he dismissed the statistical claim: Oh, no, it cant be. Im sorry. I dont mean to take a position yet. But, look, Albert Einstein had the theory of relativity without any empirical evidence, O.K.?
The United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, in San Francisco, ruled in favor of the shareholders, saying the case should go back to the trial court. The Supreme Court should do the same. The appeals court said a jury should answer these legal questions: Was the information at issue material? Would a reasonable shareholder consider it important?
In a friend of the court filing, the government argued that the court has long held that if an investor would have viewed a new piece of information as meaningfully altering the total mix of information available, it has been considered material. Instead, Matrixx is proposing an isolated yes-or-no rule: unless a claim about a product is shown to be statistically significant, there is no reason to tell investors about it.
As some professors put it in a brief supporting the shareholders, requiring that high a standard to shield investors from unproven allegations would treat them as nitwits unable to make their own judgments about good and bad information. The information in this case was spot on. Matrixx recalled Zicam in 2009, after the Food and Drug Administration warned consumers not to use it.
On Monday, Justice Elena Kagan posed this hypothetical: 10 users of a new contact lens solution go blind. There is no way that anybody would tell you that these 10 cases are statistically significant, she said. Would Matrixxs counsel stop using the product? Would a reasonable investor want to know about the 10 cases?
Matrixxs lawyer, predictably, said he wouldnt want the information. A show of hands in the packed courtroom would likely have yielded enough yeses to feel statistically significant.
New York Times
April 18, 2011
The Nose May Not Know What Its Missing
By Jane E. Brody
Dr. Ronald DeVere, a neurologist in Austin, Tex., was baffled. In 1995, after
recovering from a viral infection, something happened to his sense of smell.
Fresh milk smelled sour, the dirty dog pen smelled good, and other odors couldnt
be detected at all.
After weeks passed without improvement, he consulted experts at the University of Pennsylvania Smell and Taste Center, one of 11 such clinics now scattered around the country. Tests there showed that as a result of his illness, hed lost 70 percent of his ability to smell.
In the years since, Dr. DeVere has recovered much of his ability to smell and taste. But the experience inspired him to open his own clinic for smell and taste disorders and, most recently, to write a book, Navigating Smell and Taste Disorders (Demos Health), about this poorly understood and often unrecognized problem.
In an interview, Dr. DeVere said he hoped the book would help not only patients with smell and taste disorders but also their physicians, most of whom know little about these problems, he said, and often tell sufferers that nothing can be done youll have to live with it.
The book was written with his sister-in-law, Marjorie Calvert, an accomplished cook who provided a food preparation guide and dozens of recipes some contributed by patients that can help restore dining pleasure to those affected. Taste is mostly a result of odor detection, so the recipes emphasize spice, texture and temperature, sensations that remain unimpaired even when smell malfunctions.
Youve no doubt experienced a temporary disruption in smell and taste while suffering from a cold or sinus infection. Try to imagine your life if the problem lasted indefinitely and you could no longer enjoy the flavor of an orange or chocolate or taste the difference between chicken and steak.
But smell and taste disorders can affect more than the ability to smell the roses in life and toenjoy food. Also affected is the ability to detect and correct unpleasant smells, like body odor or a dirty diaper in need of changing. For people like professional cooks and firefighters, the problem can force an occupational switch.
Most important, smell disorders can be downright dangerous for those who cannot detect the odor of smoke, burning or spoiled food, natural gas or other noxious aromas.
An Underrecognized Problem
While reliable statistics are hard to come by, several million Americans are thought to suffer from the major smell disorders: hyposmia, a reduced ability to detect certain odors; anosmia, an inability to detect any odors at all; or dysosmia, in which pleasant odors can smell foul or vice versa.
Most people who think they have a taste disorder, usually because food has lost its flavor, turn out to have a smell problem, according to Richard M. Costanzo, a neurophysiologist at Virginia Commonwealth University. The smell disorders clinic there receives regular inquiries from distressed patients; one of them said his inability to taste food flavors was a very life-altering experience, and most normal people cannot understand the impact it has on ones life.
There are many common causes. In addition to viral infections like colds and flu, they include disorders of the nose (for example, polyps) or sinuses; injuries to the nose or head; medications like blood pressure drugs, antibiotics, cholesterol-lowering drugs, antidepressants and cancer chemotherapy; radiation therapy of the head and neck; exposure to toxins like formaldehyde and pesticides; smoking and alcohol abuse; diseases of the thyroid, kidneys, liver or pancreas; and neurological disorders like Parkinsons disease, Lewy body disease, multiple sclerosis and various kinds of dementia.
Half of all people with diabetes have a diminished sense of smell and taste, and 90 percent of those with Alzheimers disease have impaired smell capacity, Dr. DeVere said.
By far the leading cause and the one least often recognized is advancing age. Whereas only 1 percent to 2 percent of young people are affected, a quarter of those over 55 and nearly two-thirds of those over 80 have a diminished sense of smell.
But unlike vision or hearing loss, which is often apparent to others, if not to the afflicted person, a loss of smell sensitivity with age is often undetected because it occurs gradually. The result can be a diminished interest in food and gradual weight loss, or a tendency to over-season foods with salt or sugar, which may impair control of high blood pressure or diabetes, common problems in the elderly.
Depending on the cause of a smell disorder, therapeutic possibilities include treatment with nasal decongestants, antihistamines, or antibiotics; surgery to remove nasal polyps; use of a nasal saline solution; correction of hormonal or nutrient deficiencies; and stopping smoking.
Dr. DeVere said that over time smell disorders may gradually diminish in intensity, as his did. Nonetheless, Dr. Costanzo said: We have to be fair to patients. Theres no magic bullet. Some smell problems are treatable, most are not.
Especially challenging are those that result from head injuries, whether minor or severe, that disrupt the function of the bodys smell receptors olfactory nerve cells that lie outside the brain. These cells pick up odor molecules high in the nose and transmit scent messages to the brains olfactory bulb, he explained.
A head blow can injure or tear olfactory nerves. Damaged olfactory nerve cells can regenerate, but dont always reconnect properly in the brain. Dr. Costanzo and colleagues are working on grafts and transplants that may one day overcome current treatment limitations.
While everyone should have working smoke detectors in their homes, a person with a smell disorder should also have a detector for natural gas or propane, lest a leak go undetected and result in an explosion.
Perishable foods should be dated and kept refrigerated, and discarded when they expire. It may be wise for a person with normal olfactory function to check these foods before someone with an impaired sense of smell eats them.
Make sure all cleaning and garden products are properly labeled and stored separately from foods.
When cooking or baking, check periodically to make sure nothing is burning, and set a timer to ring when the food will be done.
Since you cant rely on a sniff test, be sure to bathe and launder clothes regularly. Use underarm deodorant, and go easy with cologne. Regularly check diapers for visual signs that a change is needed.
For more information, consult the Web site of the National Institute on Deafness and Other Communication Disorders at www.nidcd.nih.gov/health/smelltaste.
The Daily Mail
August 16, 2011
Wonder what it's like to have no sense of smell? It stinks!
By Kate Battersby
As I was sitting in the office one day, a colleague at a desk 3ft away looked up with a curious expression. She glanced around searchingly until her gaze settled on me.
‘My dear, she said in her customary grand manner, are you wearing perfume?
I nodded, replying: Do you like it? She smiled at me graciously.
Its simply frightful, she announced at a volume akin to the average loudhailer, adding: So cheap!
Choosing perfume by guesswork is just one of the pitfalls of my life as an anosmic a person with no sense of smell.
From the fragrance of roses to the smell of burning, Im oblivious to them all.
I am among the one in 5,000 people born anosmic others lose their sense of smell through head trauma (Tottenham manager Harry Redknapp lost his after a car crash) or as the result of a simple flu or cold virus.
Its thought that 200,000 Britons have anosmia famous sufferers have included William Wordsworth, INXS singer Michael Hutchence and actor Bill Pullman.
Yet the vast majority of people able to smell have not only never heard of anosmia, but its existence has not occurred to them. The unfailing response I receive is a blank stare, before they insist: But you must be able to smell baking bread or sour milk.
If I were blind, no one would say: But you must be able to see this very large mountain or that very bright light. So, to repeat . . . I. Cant. Smell. At all.
The estimated number of anosmics is likely to be hugely inaccurate because most just cope and never mention it, says smell specialist Professor Tim Jacob, of Cardiff Universitys School of Biosciences.
Lots of congenital anosmics say they dont even realise they have no sense of smell until their teens.
'As young children they cant understand the concept of smell but do not wish to appear different to their peers, so they learn the appropriate reactions to good or bad smells from other peoples cues.
He adds: To most people anosmia is unimportant. The condition hasnt even entered the consciousness of the medical profession. It has no NHS budget and GPs have no idea about it.
Even ear, nose and throat specialists arent trained in anosmia, according to Professor Jacob, despite the fact that dozens of viruses of the upper respiratory tract can cause it.
He says: I get letters constantly from people who feel very let down
by the medical profession and who are desperate for answers.
The fact is those answers are few. Put simply, our ability to smell is generated by receptor nerve cells at the top of the nose these send signals via the olfactory nerves to the olfactory cortex in the brain.
In anosmia, the olfactory nerves are damaged or die (people born with anosmia may lack these nerves completely this form of the condition is genetic, although it can skip generations).
In anosmia caused by head trauma or virus, the olfactory nerve is damaged, explains Professor Jacob.
Most human nerves do not regenerate. If they get broken or cut, thats that, although research is progressing.
In other words, anosmics are largely stuck with it. Those with acquired anosmia may experience the temporary return of smell for reasons not yet understood. They may also experience phantosmia the detection of an odour where none is present.
It works the same way as phantom pains in a lost limb, explains Professor Jacob.
If you no longer receive sensory input from the nose, then the brain regions dealing with smell receive random information.Then whats left of the nerve pathway can trigger the region of the brain dealing with smell, triggering an apparent smell even though there is none.
This is the case with investment banker Ben Colegrave, 30, who became anosmic after a life-threatening head injury in a road accident seven years ago.
The other day my girlfriend and I got into a taxi which to me smelled strongly of curry, he recalls.
But my girlfriend said there was no smell of curry. That happens every now and again.
I miss the memory triggers of smells, and being able to associate a smell with an individual person. Above all I miss the excitement of breathing in an unfamiliar aroma as you get off the plane in a new country.
Ben is sanguine about his anosmia (I could have died, so it doesnt seem very important), but loss of smell can be devastating.
According to Professor Jacob, 17 per cent of people who become anosmic subsequently suffer clinical depression, often because their sensory experience of food is so depleted.
Anosmics retain a normal sense of taste, distinguishing between sweet, sour, salt, bitter and umami (savoury) like everyone else.
However, we cant distinguish between flavours, as this is almost entirely down to smell. Molly Birnbaum was 20 and a would-be chef when a head injury in a road accident left her anosmic.
Food had been my consuming passion, says Birnbaum, now a writer, in her just published book Season To Taste.
Then I dreaded eating. The scent of garlic and roasting meat fell on lifeless olfactory nerves. A bite of steak may as well have been a chunk of warm cardboard.
I examined every piece of food. That milk: fresh or sour? That spinach: new or old? I had only the visual to guide me.
Professor Jacob says anosmics use other signals, such as texture, acidity and hydration, to compensate for absence of flavour. Ben Cohen, of ice cream duo Ben & Jerrys, is a congenital anosmic and insisted on large chunks in their products to improve his perception of flavour.
Of course, smell also acts as a hazard warning, says Professor Jacob, not only against lethal dangers such as gas or fire, but against food which is going off. As someone whos accidentally eaten rotten fish, I can confirm it is unbelievably disgusting.
Researchers are garnering scattered facts about anosmia. Diminished ability to smell can be an early sign of Parkinsons.
Some of the main brain degeneration seen in Parkinsons is seen first in the olfactory bulb (where the olfactory nerves meet), says Professor Jacob.
That said, many men lose around half their sense of smell by the age of 80 simply as a function of age. Women tend to retain it.
Anosmia is also linked to loss of libido, though again, its not clear why.
As for us congenitals, we rarely think about our anosmia, as it has always been our normality.
But I do quite often wonder if either I or my house smell terrible, and people are simply too polite to tell me. And Ive learned it pays to take a friend along when buying perfume.